Re: [問題] 卡卡頌火龍小豬主教的一些問題

看板BoardGame作者laycelin (浩渺之鷹)時間12年前 (2012/02/12 18:30)推噓1(1推 0噓 2→)

留言3則, 1人參與討論串5/6 (看更多)

※ 引述《finhisky (Roy)》之銘言： : : 9.如果抽到壞公主版塊，是否可以放置在自己的城堡板塊上? : : 而不踢自己的米寶? : 似乎這個問題在不同版的的規則中，有不同答案 : 我之前PO的規則是根據 Completely Annotated Rules : 最詳盡的玩家整合規則，但是否最正確我不知道 : 該規則結論是:放置公主版塊時，玩家可以決定"是否"要移除一個隨從 : http://www.carcassonnecentral.com/forum/index.php?topic=38.0 : http://www.carcassonnecentral.com/forum/index.php?topic=587.0 : 以下為該規則原文 : ---------------------------------------- : The princess : If a player draws a tile with a princess, it may be placed according to the : usualrules. If the player uses the tile to extend a city which is already : occupied byone or more knights, the player may(107) remove one knight (big or : small) from the city and return it to its owner. : ‧ If there are knights of several players in the city, the player placing the : tile may freely choose which knight is to be removed. : ‧ If the last knight of a player is removed from a city in which that player : also has a builder, then the builder is also removed and returned to the : player. : ‧ If a knight is removed from the city, the player may not deploy or move : any other figure (follower, builder, pig or fairy). : 107 This is a change to the original rules, which stated that the princess : must remove a knight, unless there was no knight in the city at all. The : change brings the procedure in line with that of the tower: : both may remove a follower if the player wishes. : The RGG edition of the Big Box still says that princesses must remove a : follower. RIO官網上放出來的規則 Carcassonne The Princess & The Dragon http://www.riograndegames.com/uploads/Game/Game_53_gameRules.pdf 節錄其中部分 When a player draws and places a princess tile, he places it following the normal rules. If he places the tile so that it adds to a city with one or more knights, he must return one of those knights to its player (his choice). In this case, he may not place a follower on this tile, even on the field or the road. If he places the tile so that it adds to an empty city, or only starts a new city, he may place a follower in the normal ways. BIG BOX BigBox1 http://www.riograndegames.com/uploads/Game/Game_50_gameRules.pdf BigBox2 http://www.riograndegames.com/uploads/Game/Game_304_gameRules.pdf BigBOx3 http://www.riograndegames.com/uploads/Game/Game_366_gameRules.pdf 裡面提的部分 When a player draws and places a princess tile, he places it following the normal rules. If he places the tile so that it adds to a city with one or more knights, he must return one of those knights to its player (his choice, and he may choose a large or normal sized follower). In this case, he may not place a follower (or any other figure) on this tile, even on the field or the road. If he removes the last knight from the city that has a builder of the same color, he removes the builder, as well. If he places the tile so that it adds to an empty city, or only starts a new city, he may place a follower (or other figure) in the normal ways. 兩者都是說必須拔一個回家（大小隨你意，若該色只剩工程師也請一併帶回）然後踢人啥都不能放，不管是米寶、小豬、工程師，還是想移動仙子都不行至於德版的規則....我看不懂＠＠所以沒去找 -- 至於您po的規則原文最後也提到了RIO Grande Game的BIG BOX規則還是沒改＠＠ so...這我覺得就開始前大家約定說好就好＠＠ -- 我所居兮，青埂之峰；我所遊兮，濛鴻太空。誰與我遊兮，吾誰與從？渺渺茫茫兮，歸彼大荒！ -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 123.204.178.121

推

finhisky

02/12 18:40, , 1^F

02/12 18:40, 1^F

→

finhisky

02/12 18:42, , 2^F

02/12 18:42, 2^F

→

finhisky

02/12 18:42, , 3^F

02/12 18:42, 3^F