Fw: [新聞] JVC回函澄清:蔣偉寧是無辜受害者之一
※ [本文轉錄自 Gossiping 看板 #1JnAx1s4 ]
作者: orz11111 (老人=剩下一張嘴=沒有用) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [新聞] JVC回函澄清:蔣偉寧是無辜受害者之一
時間: Tue Jul 15 12:31:57 2014
http://udn.com/NEWS/BREAKINGNEWS/BREAKINGNEWS1/8805105.shtml?instant
【聯合晚報╱記者王彩鸝╱即時報導】 2014.07.15 11:24 am
《國際震動及控制期刊》 (JVC)撤銷陳震遠論文自審造假案相關的60篇文章,其中五篇教
育部長蔣偉寧共同掛名,蔣因此一風波昨天請辭下台。
JVC今天凌晨1時49分回函蔣偉寧,信中明確指出,蔣五篇文章被撤與抄襲無關,而是投稿
審查過程有疑義,以致對論文內容與品質無法評量。
JVC澄清說,相信很多列名共同作者的人,包括蔣偉寧在內都是無辜受害者。
蔣偉寧今天發表聲明指出:
連日來部分媒體報導本人涉及論文造假、抄襲,甚有部分學界人士在未究明實情下,即輕
率論斷本人違反學術倫理及研究團隊集體造假,此種悖離事實的報導,傷害本人名譽,謹
嚴正澄清說明如下:
一、JVC國際期刊係以論文投稿審查過程有疑義而處理此案,並非質疑論文本身有抄襲造
假問題。JVC所屬SAGE出版公司於今(15)日回復本人及研究團隊之電子郵件亦提到:
1.我們可以肯認這些論文並非因抄襲的結果而撤回。
2. 這些論文並未經過適當且正確/合乎品質的同儕審查標準予以評估,因此我們無法評論
這些被撤回論文的內容或品質。
3.我們可以澄清,我們相信有無辜的當事人牽涉其中,並且 可能包括像您一樣列名為合
作者之人。
(We can confirm that these papers have not been retracted as a result of
plagiarism. We cannot comment on the content and quality of the retracted
papers, due to the fact that they were not assessedin line with appropriate
and correct/ quality peerreview standards.
We are able to clarify that we believe there are innocent parties involved
and which may include many of those listed as co-authors such as yourself.)
二、此外,SAGE公司之回信中亦提到,「不幸的是,提交稿件的作者並未提供您正確的聯
絡電子郵件位址,因此看來您沒有收到本公司寄給所有作者的信件有關通知撤回一事。」
(Unfortunately the submitting author on your manuscripts did not provide an
accurate contactemail address for you on the papers and therefore itappears
that you did not receive the correspondencewhich was sent to all author and
co-authorsnotifying you of the retractions.)
因此可見期刊通知確未送達及向本人求證,自然也沒有本人明知或不處理之情事。學術聲
譽累積不易,對學者而言,可謂第二生命,外界在相關事實未釐明前,不應輕易論斷本人
為共同作者之論文有實質違反學術倫理或抄襲造假之情事。
三、本人希望科技部能儘快查明此一事件,還本人及研究團隊其他成員一個公道。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 36.233.143.93
※ 文章網址: http://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1405398721.A.D84.html
※ 編輯: orz11111 (36.233.143.93), 07/15/2014 12:32:26
噓
07/15 12:32, , 1F
07/15 12:32, 1F
推
07/15 12:32, , 2F
07/15 12:32, 2F
※ 編輯: orz11111 (36.233.143.93), 07/15/2014 12:33:02
噓
07/15 12:32, , 3F
07/15 12:32, 3F
噓
07/15 12:32, , 4F
07/15 12:32, 4F
→
07/15 12:32, , 5F
07/15 12:32, 5F
噓
07/15 12:33, , 6F
07/15 12:33, 6F
推
07/15 12:33, , 7F
07/15 12:33, 7F
噓
07/15 12:33, , 8F
07/15 12:33, 8F
推
07/15 12:33, , 9F
07/15 12:33, 9F
→
07/15 12:33, , 10F
07/15 12:33, 10F
噓
07/15 12:33, , 11F
07/15 12:33, 11F
→
07/15 12:33, , 12F
07/15 12:33, 12F
推
07/15 12:33, , 13F
07/15 12:33, 13F
噓
07/15 12:33, , 14F
07/15 12:33, 14F
→
07/15 12:33, , 15F
07/15 12:33, 15F
噓
07/15 12:33, , 16F
07/15 12:33, 16F
噓
07/15 12:33, , 17F
07/15 12:33, 17F
推
07/15 12:33, , 18F
07/15 12:33, 18F
推
07/15 12:33, , 19F
07/15 12:33, 19F
噓
07/15 12:33, , 20F
07/15 12:33, 20F
噓
07/15 12:33, , 21F
07/15 12:33, 21F
→
07/15 12:34, , 22F
07/15 12:34, 22F
噓
07/15 12:34, , 23F
07/15 12:34, 23F
→
07/15 12:34, , 24F
07/15 12:34, 24F
→
07/15 12:34, , 25F
07/15 12:34, 25F
推
07/15 12:34, , 26F
07/15 12:34, 26F
噓
07/15 12:34, , 27F
07/15 12:34, 27F
推
07/15 12:34, , 28F
07/15 12:34, 28F
噓
07/15 12:34, , 29F
07/15 12:34, 29F
→
07/15 12:34, , 30F
07/15 12:34, 30F
噓
07/15 12:34, , 31F
07/15 12:34, 31F
噓
07/15 12:34, , 32F
07/15 12:34, 32F
→
07/15 12:34, , 33F
07/15 12:34, 33F
→
07/15 12:34, , 34F
07/15 12:34, 34F
推
07/15 12:35, , 35F
07/15 12:35, 35F
→
07/15 12:35, , 36F
07/15 12:35, 36F
→
07/15 12:35, , 37F
07/15 12:35, 37F
→
07/15 12:35, , 38F
07/15 12:35, 38F
→
07/15 12:35, , 39F
07/15 12:35, 39F
→
07/15 12:35, , 40F
07/15 12:35, 40F
噓
07/15 12:35, , 41F
07/15 12:35, 41F
推
07/15 12:36, , 42F
07/15 12:36, 42F
推
07/15 12:36, , 43F
07/15 12:36, 43F
噓
07/15 12:36, , 44F
07/15 12:36, 44F
→
07/15 12:36, , 45F
07/15 12:36, 45F
推
07/15 12:36, , 46F
07/15 12:36, 46F
→
07/15 12:36, , 47F
07/15 12:36, 47F
噓
07/15 12:36, , 48F
07/15 12:36, 48F
噓
07/15 12:37, , 49F
07/15 12:37, 49F
推
07/15 12:37, , 50F
07/15 12:37, 50F
→
07/15 12:37, , 51F
07/15 12:37, 51F
噓
07/15 12:37, , 52F
07/15 12:37, 52F
→
07/15 12:37, , 53F
07/15 12:37, 53F
噓
07/15 12:37, , 54F
07/15 12:37, 54F
噓
07/15 12:37, , 55F
07/15 12:37, 55F
噓
07/15 12:37, , 56F
07/15 12:37, 56F
→
07/15 12:37, , 57F
07/15 12:37, 57F
噓
07/15 12:37, , 58F
07/15 12:37, 58F
→
07/15 12:37, , 59F
07/15 12:37, 59F
→
07/15 12:37, , 60F
07/15 12:37, 60F
→
07/15 12:38, , 61F
07/15 12:38, 61F
→
07/15 12:38, , 62F
07/15 12:38, 62F
噓
07/15 12:38, , 63F
07/15 12:38, 63F
噓
07/15 12:38, , 64F
07/15 12:38, 64F
→
07/15 12:38, , 65F
07/15 12:38, 65F
噓
07/15 12:38, , 66F
07/15 12:38, 66F
→
07/15 12:38, , 67F
07/15 12:38, 67F
→
07/15 12:38, , 68F
07/15 12:38, 68F
→
07/15 12:39, , 69F
07/15 12:39, 69F
→
07/15 12:39, , 70F
07/15 12:39, 70F
→
07/15 12:39, , 71F
07/15 12:39, 71F
→
07/15 12:40, , 72F
07/15 12:40, 72F
推
07/15 12:40, , 73F
07/15 12:40, 73F
→
07/15 12:40, , 74F
07/15 12:40, 74F
噓
07/15 12:40, , 75F
07/15 12:40, 75F
噓
07/15 12:40, , 76F
07/15 12:40, 76F
→
07/15 12:41, , 77F
07/15 12:41, 77F
推
07/15 12:41, , 78F
07/15 12:41, 78F
推
07/15 12:41, , 79F
07/15 12:41, 79F
→
07/15 12:41, , 80F
07/15 12:41, 80F
推
07/15 12:41, , 81F
07/15 12:41, 81F
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
※ 轉錄者: ggg12345 (114.43.225.218), 07/15/2014 12:41:38
推
07/15 13:45, , 82F
07/15 13:45, 82F
噓
07/15 14:13, , 83F
07/15 14:13, 83F
→
07/15 14:14, , 84F
07/15 14:14, 84F
→
07/15 15:07, , 85F
07/15 15:07, 85F
→
07/15 15:08, , 86F
07/15 15:08, 86F
→
07/15 15:09, , 87F
07/15 15:09, 87F
→
07/15 15:10, , 88F
07/15 15:10, 88F
→
07/15 15:12, , 89F
07/15 15:12, 89F
→
07/15 15:13, , 90F
07/15 15:13, 90F
噓
07/15 19:51, , 91F
07/15 19:51, 91F
討論串 (同標題文章)
完整討論串 (本文為第 1 之 3 篇):