[討論] 賽德克巴萊能像星戰，成為經典拍七集嗎?
美國的星際大戰，是科幻的經典，
紅了幾十年，
賽德克巴萊有可能像星戰一樣，成為經典，
連拍七集嗎？
我個人認為是不可能，畢竟賽德克巴來出名是靠媒體炒作的，
當初正紅的時候一堆人盲從，就像到好市多秒退鮮奶一樣，
電影本身是沒什麼內容的空洞作品，
角色沒有靈魂，硬要形容的話，
就是原住民ＶＳ日本軍大亂鬥，
角色重覆的比例太高，不像星際大戰，有很多特色鮮明的角色，
像天行者、歐比王、Ｒ２Ｄ２、尤達、黑武士、韓蘇洛，一大票講都講不完，
甚至把每個角色獨立出來，另寫劇本來當主角都沒問題，
當初我就搞不懂，
魏德聖已經是台灣能運用最多資源的導演了，
為什麼靠海角七號紅了，能拍自己想拍的東西了，還在拍歷史題材的片，
真正有創意的人，像史蒂芬史匹伯、喬治盧卡斯都是擅長拍科幻片的，
為什麼台灣連２００１太空漫遊都拍不出來，
說真的，魏德聖不敢創新，這點就輸給九把刀、刀大，
可惜刀大一個蘿蔔插兩個坑，把自己的名聲弄臭掉，
沒有想像力的人掌權真的很恐怖，
台灣電影深陷在一種，只敢打歷史題材、社會題材的安全牌，
只敢去考究歷史，有範例才敢拍，真的好無聊，
不敢賭大，不敢創造像星際大戰這種夢幻題材，
說真的，我這輩子都不會原諒魏德聖的。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 116.241.161.210
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/movie/M.1449818219.A.E1E.html
噓
12/11 15:19, , 1F
12/11 15:19, 1F
噓
12/11 15:20, , 2F
12/11 15:20, 2F
噓
12/11 15:20, , 3F
12/11 15:20, 3F
推
12/11 15:21, , 4F
12/11 15:21, 4F
噓
12/11 15:28, , 5F
12/11 15:28, 5F
噓
12/11 15:29, , 6F
12/11 15:29, 6F
噓
12/11 15:31, , 7F
12/11 15:31, 7F
噓
12/11 15:32, , 8F
12/11 15:32, 8F
噓
12/11 15:32, , 9F
12/11 15:32, 9F
噓
12/11 15:42, , 10F
12/11 15:42, 10F
噓
12/11 15:43, , 11F
12/11 15:43, 11F
→
12/11 15:43, , 12F
12/11 15:43, 12F
噓
12/11 15:50, , 13F
12/11 15:50, 13F
噓
12/11 15:55, , 14F
12/11 15:55, 14F
噓
12/11 16:04, , 15F
12/11 16:04, 15F
推
12/11 16:05, , 16F
12/11 16:05, 16F
噓
12/11 16:06, , 17F
12/11 16:06, 17F
噓
12/11 16:10, , 18F
12/11 16:10, 18F
噓
12/11 16:11, , 19F
12/11 16:11, 19F
噓
12/11 16:17, , 20F
12/11 16:17, 20F
→
12/11 16:17, , 21F
12/11 16:17, 21F
噓
12/11 16:18, , 22F
12/11 16:18, 22F
推
12/11 16:19, , 23F
12/11 16:19, 23F
→
12/11 16:20, , 24F
12/11 16:20, 24F
→
12/11 16:20, , 25F
12/11 16:20, 25F
噓
12/11 16:25, , 26F
12/11 16:25, 26F
推
12/11 16:39, , 27F
12/11 16:39, 27F
噓
12/11 16:47, , 28F
12/11 16:47, 28F
噓
12/11 16:52, , 29F
12/11 16:52, 29F
噓
12/11 17:02, , 30F
12/11 17:02, 30F
噓
12/11 17:08, , 31F
12/11 17:08, 31F
噓
12/11 17:08, , 32F
12/11 17:08, 32F
噓
12/11 17:12, , 33F
12/11 17:12, 33F
噓
12/11 17:15, , 34F
12/11 17:15, 34F
噓
12/11 17:19, , 35F
12/11 17:19, 35F
噓
12/11 17:23, , 36F
12/11 17:23, 36F
推
12/11 17:27, , 37F
12/11 17:27, 37F
→
12/11 17:28, , 38F
12/11 17:28, 38F
推
12/11 17:40, , 39F
12/11 17:40, 39F
→
12/11 17:54, , 40F
12/11 17:54, 40F
推
12/11 17:56, , 41F
12/11 17:56, 41F
噓
12/11 18:03, , 42F
12/11 18:03, 42F
→
12/11 18:08, , 43F
12/11 18:08, 43F
推
12/11 18:10, , 44F
12/11 18:10, 44F
→
12/11 18:11, , 45F
12/11 18:11, 45F
推
12/11 18:13, , 46F
12/11 18:13, 46F
噓
12/11 18:32, , 47F
12/11 18:32, 47F
→
12/11 18:33, , 48F
12/11 18:33, 48F
→
12/11 18:34, , 49F
12/11 18:34, 49F
噓
12/11 18:38, , 50F
12/11 18:38, 50F
噓
12/11 18:44, , 51F
12/11 18:44, 51F
推
12/11 18:58, , 52F
12/11 18:58, 52F
噓
12/11 19:13, , 53F
12/11 19:13, 53F
→
12/11 19:15, , 54F
12/11 19:15, 54F
噓
12/11 19:23, , 55F
12/11 19:23, 55F
→
12/11 19:31, , 56F
12/11 19:31, 56F
噓
12/11 19:41, , 57F
12/11 19:41, 57F
噓
12/11 19:42, , 58F
12/11 19:42, 58F
噓
12/11 19:50, , 59F
12/11 19:50, 59F
→
12/11 19:50, , 60F
12/11 19:50, 60F
噓
12/11 20:02, , 61F
12/11 20:02, 61F
噓
12/11 20:22, , 62F
12/11 20:22, 62F
噓
12/11 20:32, , 63F
12/11 20:32, 63F
噓
12/11 21:45, , 64F
12/11 21:45, 64F
→
12/11 21:50, , 65F
12/11 21:50, 65F
→
12/12 00:30, , 66F
12/12 00:30, 66F
→
12/12 00:30, , 67F
12/12 00:30, 67F
噓
12/12 00:43, , 68F
12/12 00:43, 68F
噓
12/12 00:59, , 69F
12/12 00:59, 69F
噓
12/12 01:00, , 70F
12/12 01:00, 70F
噓
12/12 01:07, , 71F
12/12 01:07, 71F
噓
12/12 01:49, , 72F
12/12 01:49, 72F
推
12/12 02:41, , 73F
12/12 02:41, 73F
噓
12/12 06:03, , 74F
12/12 06:03, 74F
噓
12/12 09:25, , 75F
12/12 09:25, 75F
噓
12/12 11:57, , 76F
12/12 11:57, 76F
噓
12/12 11:59, , 77F
12/12 11:59, 77F
噓
12/12 14:31, , 78F
12/12 14:31, 78F
噓
12/12 16:34, , 79F
12/12 16:34, 79F
噓
12/12 20:05, , 80F
12/12 20:05, 80F
噓
12/12 20:21, , 81F
12/12 20:21, 81F
噓
12/12 21:55, , 82F
12/12 21:55, 82F
噓
12/13 00:30, , 83F
12/13 00:30, 83F
噓
12/13 09:14, , 84F
12/13 09:14, 84F
噓
12/14 10:46, , 85F
12/14 10:46, 85F
噓
12/14 13:21, , 86F
12/14 13:21, 86F
噓
12/14 21:12, , 87F
12/14 21:12, 87F
噓
12/17 09:51, , 88F
12/17 09:51, 88F
推
03/19 23:35, , 89F
03/19 23:35, 89F