[評鑑] 最新上海交大全世界大學工程領域總排名
上海交通大學最新公佈的全世界大學分領域排名
原始網址: http://ed.sjtu.edu.cn/ARWU-FIELD2008.htm
排名方法: http://ed.sjtu.edu.cn/ARWU-FIELD2008/FIELD-Methodology2008.htm
這個排名的特點在於不論學校的名氣多響亮，都要撇開先入為主的主觀意識，
並要老老實實地被客觀計算出學術表現。
從排名方法的網頁可知，校友表現,得獎表現(Nobel Prize & Fields Medals),
研究論文發表的表現,研究經費等都會納入學術表現的計算。
比起U.S. News ＆ World Report將研究所入學錄取率和GRE分數納入評分，
上海交大的這份排名顯然客觀高明多了。此外也不需要逢中國就必反，
難道美國人與U.S. News說的就一定是對的嗎?
其實U.S.News工學院排名著重在聲望因素的排名
(USNews排名: http://grad-schools.usnews.rankingsandreviews.com/grad/eng/search)
(USNews排名方法: http://tinyurl.com/6mreud)
而上海交大著重在實質的學術研究表現與論文發表的排名，也就是科研實力的排序
由於之前只有U.S.News排名，因此只提供了一種角度來看學校
現在上海交大排名的出現，正好提供了另一個客觀的角度，
讓我們得以檢視哪些學校是名實相符，而又哪些學校是名過其實。
其實大家不仿檢視一下上海交大工學院排名前10名
會發現大部分的學校也都出現在U.S.News工學院排名前10名
即 MIT, UIUC, UC Berkeley, Stanford, Michigan等名校
也就是說這些學校真的是名實相符，甚至實過其名；
反之，一些學校就難免有名過其實，靠著舊日光輝及一些title在撐場面之虞
至於美國的大學會不會看之前上海交大所做的排名? 其實可以從以下網頁略知一二:
http://www.coe.berkeley.edu/forefront/fall2005/rankings.html
http://www.cs.ucsb.edu/department/choose_ucsb/
http://viterbi.usc.edu/news/news/2007/viterbi-school-engineering.htm
http://www.cmu.edu/news/rankings/university-rankings.shtml
http://ucsdnews.ucsd.edu/about/index.html
http://www.engr.uiuc.edu/about/rankings.php
至於台灣的學術界會不會看之前上海交大所做的排名?
台大 http://www.alum.ntu.edu.tw/read.php?num=41&sn=845
交大 http://www.pac.nctu.edu.tw/Report/report_more.php?id=10335
清大 http://www.nthu.edu.tw/newsphoto/96news/hotnews-960828.php
這篇排名涵蓋了所有的工程領域,以及電腦科學CS領域，並不是只有CS的範疇而已
Top 100 world universities in Engineering/Technology and Computer Sciences
Rank Institution Country
------------------------------------------------------
1 Massachusetts Inst Tech (MIT) USA
2 Stanford Univ USA
3 Univ Illinois - Urbana Champaign USA
4 Univ California - Berkeley USA
5 Univ Michigan - Ann Arbor USA
6 Univ Texas - Austin USA
7 Carnegie Mellon Univ USA
8 Georgia Inst Tech USA
9 Pennsylvania State Univ - Univ Park USA
10 Univ California - San Diego USA
11 Univ Southern California USA
12 California Inst Tech USA
13 Univ California - Santa Barbara USA
13 Univ Maryland - Coll Park USA
15 Univ Cambridge UK
16 Cornell Univ USA
17 Purdue Univ - West Lafayette USA
18 Swiss Fed Inst Tech - Lausanne Switzerland
19 Tohoku Univ Japan
20 Northwestern Univ USA
21 Univ Toronto Canada
22 Ohio State Univ - Columbus USA
23 Kyoto Univ Japan
24 Princeton Univ USA
25 Imperial Coll London UK
25 North Carolina State Univ USA
27 Univ Washington - Seattle USA
27 Univ Wisconsin - Madison USA
29 Natl Univ Singapore Singapore
29 Tokyo Inst Tech Japan
31 Univ Minnesota - Twin Cities USA
32 Univ California - Los Angeles USA
33 Univ Florida USA
34 Texas A&M Univ - Coll Station USA
35 Univ Manchester UK
36 Univ Pennsylvania USA
37 Harvard Univ USA
38 Rutgers State Univ USA
39 Technion Israel Inst Tech Israel
40 Hong Kong Univ Sci & Tech China-hk
41 Univ California - Irvine USA
42 Osaka Univ Japan
43 Columbia Univ USA
44 Univ California - Davis USA
44 Univ Massachusetts - Amherst USA
46 Virginia Tech USA
47 Univ Oxford UK
48 Univ Colorado - Boulder USA
49 McGill Univ Canada
50 Tsinghua Univ China
51-75 Chalmers Univ Tech Sweden
51-75 City Univ Hong Kong China-hk
51-75 Duke Univ USA
51-75 Nanyang Tech Univ Singapore
51-75 Natl Chiao Tung Univ China-tw (應為Taiwan)
51-75 Natl Taiwan Univ China-tw (應為Taiwan)
51-75 Polytechnic Inst Turin Italy
51-75 Rensselaer Polytechnic Inst USA
51-75 Rice Univ USA
51-75 Seoul Natl Univ South Korea
51-75 Swiss Fed Inst Tech - Zurich Switzerland
51-75 Tech Univ Denmark Denmark
51-75 Tel Aviv Univ Israel
51-75 Tokyo Univ Japan
51-75 Univ Bordeaux 1 France
51-75 Univ British Columbia Canada
51-75 Univ Delaware USA
51-75 Univ Leuven Belgium
51-75 Univ Melbourne Australia
51-75 Univ Paris 06 France
51-75 Univ Sci & Tech China China
51-75 Univ Sheffield UK
51-75 Univ Sydney Australia
51-75 Univ Twente Netherlands
51-75 Univ Virginia USA
76-107 Arizona State Univ - Tempe USA
76-107 Boston Univ USA
76-107 Case Western Reserve Univ USA
76-107 Chinese Univ Hong Kong China-hk
76-107 Delft Univ Tech Netherlands
76-107 Hokkaido Univ Japan
76-107 Indian Inst Sci India
76-107 Indian Inst Tech - Kharagpur India
76-107 Iowa State Univ USA
76-107 Johns Hopkins Univ USA
76-107 Korea Advanced Inst Sci & Tech South Korea
76-107 Kyushu Univ Japan
76-107 Lund Univ Sweden
76-107 Michigan State Univ USA
76-107 Pohang Univ Sci & Tech South Korea
76-107 Shanghai Jiao Tong Univ China
76-107 Tech Univ Munich Germany
76-107 Univ Alberta Canada
76-107 Univ Bristol UK
76-107 Univ California - Riverside USA
76-107 Univ Louvain Belgium
76-107 Univ Montreal Canada
76-107 Univ Naples Federico II Italy
76-107 Univ New South Wales Australia
76-107 Univ Roma - La Sapienza Italy
76-107 Univ Southampton UK
76-107 Univ Utah USA
76-107 Univ Utrecht Netherlands
76-107 Univ Waterloo Canada
76-107 Uppsala Univ Sweden
76-107 Yale Univ USA
76-107 Zhejiang Univ China
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 118.169.210.37
推
04/22 08:11,
04/22 08:11
推
04/22 08:30,
04/22 08:30
推
04/22 08:49,
04/22 08:49
推
04/22 10:36,
04/22 10:36
→
04/22 10:37,
04/22 10:37
推
04/22 10:39,
04/22 10:39
推
04/22 10:42,
04/22 10:42
推
04/22 11:34,
04/22 11:34
推
04/22 13:58,
04/22 13:58
→
04/22 14:01,
04/22 14:01
→
04/22 14:02,
04/22 14:02
→
04/22 14:06,
04/22 14:06
→
04/22 14:14,
04/22 14:14
→
04/22 14:18,
04/22 14:18
推
04/22 14:26,
04/22 14:26
推
04/22 14:30,
04/22 14:30
→
04/22 14:30,
04/22 14:30
→
04/22 14:32,
04/22 14:32
推
04/22 15:21,
04/22 15:21
→
04/22 15:22,
04/22 15:22
→
04/22 15:24,
04/22 15:24
→
04/22 15:25,
04/22 15:25
推
04/22 16:15,
04/22 16:15
推
04/22 17:05,
04/22 17:05
※ 編輯: AirWade 來自: 118.169.212.11 (04/22 17:55)
推
04/23 00:05,
04/23 00:05
→
04/23 00:05,
04/23 00:05
推
04/23 00:07,
04/23 00:07
→
04/23 00:08,
04/23 00:08
→
04/23 00:10,
04/23 00:10
→
04/23 00:12,
04/23 00:12
→
04/23 00:13,
04/23 00:13
→
04/23 04:00,
04/23 04:00
→
04/23 04:00,
04/23 04:00
推
04/23 05:21,
04/23 05:21
※ 編輯: AirWade 來自: 118.169.213.191 (04/23 21:46)
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 118.169.211.212
※ 編輯: AirWade 來自: 118.169.211.212 (04/25 02:24)
※ 編輯: AirWade 來自: 118.160.234.226 (06/23 00:32)