[分享] 關於洪蘭的"講理就好"書內部分內容 (不喜勿入)
分享一篇好文章
裡面提及洪蘭文章和她所寫的書"講理就好"的許多荒謬之處
哎....原來洪蘭這種荒謬的情形已經這麼多年了
這種人居然可以在學術圈和社會上招搖撞騙生存這麼久...我真覺得不可思議了
以下是連結文章
http://blog.roodo.com/weichen/archives/10819475.html
2007年7月29日，洪蘭又很不爽醫科生不知道亞美尼亞在哪裡。（又是聯合晚報，撰稿記者謝蕙蓮。）不過，在她大發雷霆的前幾天，聯合報副刊在2007年7月8日才刊出其演講「新科技帶來的新知識」，洪蘭大言不慚地指出「亞歷山大曾說過：『我來、我見、我征服。』」這句話是凱撒說的耶！
洪蘭還在她的書《講理就好》提及「莫札特和舒伯特是差不多同一時期（莫札特1756～91，舒伯特1797～1828），作品風格都很相似，當學生聽莫札特有效應，聽舒伯特沒有效應時，我們就應該對它存疑了。」一個是古典樂派，一個是浪漫樂派，兩者曲風大為迥異，怎麼會產生相同的效應？如果說莫札特和舒伯特作品風格都很相似，那不如說李斯特跟李希特是同學算了。
顯然，洪蘭的人文素養、常識、知識也都嚴重不足。
------------------
反洪蘭謬譯:糟蹋圖書、誤人子弟
http://ppt.cc/PF1j
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 115.165.238.243
→
12/19 00:01, , 1F
12/19 00:01, 1F
→
12/19 00:02, , 2F
12/19 00:02, 2F
→
12/19 00:04, , 3F
12/19 00:04, 3F
→
12/19 00:05, , 4F
12/19 00:05, 4F
→
12/19 00:08, , 5F
12/19 00:08, 5F
→
12/19 00:10, , 6F
12/19 00:10, 6F
推
12/19 00:12, , 7F
12/19 00:12, 7F
→
12/19 00:15, , 8F
12/19 00:15, 8F
噓
12/19 00:22, , 9F
12/19 00:22, 9F
→
12/19 00:23, , 10F
12/19 00:23, 10F
→
12/19 00:25, , 11F
12/19 00:25, 11F
→
12/19 00:27, , 12F
12/19 00:27, 12F
→
12/19 00:28, , 13F
12/19 00:28, 13F
→
12/19 00:28, , 14F
12/19 00:28, 14F
→
12/19 00:29, , 15F
12/19 00:29, 15F
→
12/19 00:29, , 16F
12/19 00:29, 16F
→
12/19 00:29, , 17F
12/19 00:29, 17F
→
12/19 00:36, , 18F
12/19 00:36, 18F
→
12/19 00:36, , 19F
12/19 00:36, 19F
→
12/19 00:38, , 20F
12/19 00:38, 20F
噓
12/19 00:38, , 21F
12/19 00:38, 21F
→
12/19 00:39, , 22F
12/19 00:39, 22F
→
12/19 00:39, , 23F
12/19 00:39, 23F
→
12/19 00:40, , 24F
12/19 00:40, 24F
→
12/19 00:40, , 25F
12/19 00:40, 25F
→
12/19 00:40, , 26F
12/19 00:40, 26F
→
12/19 00:41, , 27F
12/19 00:41, 27F
→
12/19 00:41, , 28F
12/19 00:41, 28F
推
12/19 00:41, , 29F
12/19 00:41, 29F
→
12/19 00:41, , 30F
12/19 00:41, 30F
→
12/19 00:42, , 31F
12/19 00:42, 31F
→
12/19 00:42, , 32F
12/19 00:42, 32F
→
12/19 00:42, , 33F
12/19 00:42, 33F
→
12/19 00:42, , 34F
12/19 00:42, 34F
→
12/19 00:42, , 35F
12/19 00:42, 35F
→
12/19 00:43, , 36F
12/19 00:43, 36F
→
12/19 00:43, , 37F
12/19 00:43, 37F
→
12/19 00:43, , 38F
12/19 00:43, 38F
→
12/19 00:43, , 39F
12/19 00:43, 39F
還有 167 則推文
→
12/19 08:10, , 207F
12/19 08:10, 207F
→
12/19 08:13, , 208F
12/19 08:13, 208F
→
12/19 08:15, , 209F
12/19 08:15, 209F
→
12/19 08:15, , 210F
12/19 08:15, 210F
推
12/19 08:16, , 211F
12/19 08:16, 211F
→
12/19 08:17, , 212F
12/19 08:17, 212F
→
12/19 08:17, , 213F
12/19 08:17, 213F
→
12/19 08:17, , 214F
12/19 08:17, 214F
→
12/19 08:18, , 215F
12/19 08:18, 215F
→
12/19 08:18, , 216F
12/19 08:18, 216F
→
12/19 08:18, , 217F
12/19 08:18, 217F
→
12/19 08:18, , 218F
12/19 08:18, 218F
推
12/19 08:21, , 219F
12/19 08:21, 219F
推
12/19 08:21, , 220F
12/19 08:21, 220F
→
12/19 08:38, , 221F
12/19 08:38, 221F
※ 編輯: huanglove 來自: 115.165.238.243 (12/19 08:42)
→
12/19 08:40, , 222F
12/19 08:40, 222F
推
12/19 08:42, , 223F
12/19 08:42, 223F
→
12/19 08:42, , 224F
12/19 08:42, 224F
→
12/19 08:43, , 225F
12/19 08:43, 225F
→
12/19 08:43, , 226F
12/19 08:43, 226F
推
12/19 08:46, , 227F
12/19 08:46, 227F
→
12/19 08:46, , 228F
12/19 08:46, 228F
推
12/19 08:47, , 229F
12/19 08:47, 229F
→
12/19 08:47, , 230F
12/19 08:47, 230F
→
12/19 08:51, , 231F
12/19 08:51, 231F
→
12/19 08:52, , 232F
12/19 08:52, 232F
→
12/19 08:52, , 233F
12/19 08:52, 233F
→
12/19 08:57, , 234F
12/19 08:57, 234F
→
12/19 08:58, , 235F
12/19 08:58, 235F
噓
12/19 18:10, , 236F
12/19 18:10, 236F
→
12/19 18:11, , 237F
12/19 18:11, 237F
→
12/19 18:14, , 238F
12/19 18:14, 238F
→
12/19 18:18, , 239F
12/19 18:18, 239F
→
12/19 18:52, , 240F
12/19 18:52, 240F
推
12/19 22:31, , 241F
12/19 22:31, 241F
推
12/21 01:04, , 242F
12/21 01:04, 242F
推
12/21 18:13, , 243F
12/21 18:13, 243F
→
11/06 17:34, , 244F
11/06 17:34, 244F
→
12/31 03:27,
5年前
, 245F
12/31 03:27, 245F