[新聞]酒測攔檢搬法條 警察尬贏律師
※ [本文轉錄自 Gossiping 看板]
作者: iceyes (冰眼) 看板: Gossiping
標題: Re: [新聞] 「側摔檳榔西施」效應 嫌控警打人
時間: Sat Apr 10 01:47:35 2010
合理性懷疑 查身分證
相當性理由 開包包 搜身
下面的新聞剛好可以解釋
順便可以從新聞中看前幾天西施側摔 到底誰對誰錯
4月9日聯合報
http://udn.com/NEWS/SOCIETY/SOC6/5526286.shtml
酒測攔檢搬法條 警察尬贏律師
素有「法條背誦」高手之稱的桃園警分局大樹派出所副所長程克強,昨天凌晨執行酒測
時,轎車中一名男性律師拿出「六法全書」,質疑警方盤查的合法性;
程克強一一背誦相關條文接招,讓對方心服口服。
「我是律師,」這名男子這才透露身分,緊握程克強雙手,
連聲讚許程克強,並說「謝謝」。
警察和律師「論法」的一幕,讓在場陳姓警員大為嘆服,回派出所後轉述傳開。
程克強和陳姓員警凌晨在寶慶路設酒測攔查點,攔下由女子駕駛的轎車時,
因車內飄出酒味便要求出示證件;
駕駛座旁喝了酒的男子不滿質問:「沒喝酒(指女駕駛)為什麼要出示證件?」
男子隨即下車再問:「憑什麼盤查我們?」程克強回應,
依警察職權行使法第二章第六條(身分查證)
第一項「合理懷疑有犯罪之嫌疑或有犯罪之虞者」都可盤查身分,
「您車窗搖下時,我聞到車內濃濃酒味,符合合理懷疑要項。」
男子又出招「哪條法令規定要出示證件受檢?」程克強答,
同法第七條中(查證身分必要措施)對觸及第六條者得採取攔停
人、車、船及其他交通工具,並令出示身 分證明文件。
這時男子從包包搬出「六法全書」,再問「憑什麼在這地段封路攔檢?」
程克強回應,同法第六條第六項中「行經指定公共場所、路段及管制站者」,
經警察機關與 地方政府核可即可。
男子心想「警察一定沒帶公文」,使出絕招「請提出核可證明?」
這也沒難倒程克強,他從容地從公文夾拿出執行酒測核可公文書。
程克強受訪時說,他一再教導同仁「警察執法一定要先熟法」,
這次論法,沒有輸贏,只能說彼此進行一場路邊「法律交流」。
他表示,十七年前任職台北時,就自我要求一定要牢記執法時的法條,
他還找過同事見證,只要背錯一字就請吃消夜,
「請了好幾頓消夜,才換來這等功力。」
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.45.148.128
推
04/10 01:49,
04/10 01:49
推
04/10 01:49,
04/10 01:49
推
04/10 01:49,
04/10 01:49
推
04/10 01:49,
04/10 01:49
推
04/10 01:49,
04/10 01:49
推
04/10 01:49,
04/10 01:49
推
04/10 01:50,
04/10 01:50
推
04/10 01:50,
04/10 01:50
→
04/10 01:50,
04/10 01:50
→
04/10 01:51,
04/10 01:51
推
04/10 01:51,
04/10 01:51
推
04/10 01:51,
04/10 01:51
推
04/10 01:52,
04/10 01:52
→
04/10 01:52,
04/10 01:52
推
04/10 01:53,
04/10 01:53
→
04/10 01:53,
04/10 01:53
推
04/10 01:53,
04/10 01:53
噓
04/10 01:54,
04/10 01:54
推
04/10 01:54,
04/10 01:54
推
04/10 01:54,
04/10 01:54
推
04/10 01:55,
04/10 01:55
推
04/10 01:55,
04/10 01:55
→
04/10 01:55,
04/10 01:55
推
04/10 01:55,
04/10 01:55
→
04/10 01:55,
04/10 01:55
推
04/10 01:55,
04/10 01:55
推
04/10 01:56,
04/10 01:56
→
04/10 01:56,
04/10 01:56
→
04/10 01:56,
04/10 01:56
推
04/10 01:57,
04/10 01:57
→
04/10 01:57,
04/10 01:57
推
04/10 01:58,
04/10 01:58
→
04/10 01:59,
04/10 01:59
推
04/10 01:59,
04/10 01:59
→
04/10 01:59,
04/10 01:59
→
04/10 02:01,
04/10 02:01
推
04/10 02:04,
04/10 02:04
推
04/10 02:10,
04/10 02:10
→
04/10 02:11,
04/10 02:11
→
04/10 02:12,
04/10 02:12
推
04/10 02:12,
04/10 02:12
→
04/10 02:13,
04/10 02:13
→
04/10 02:22,
04/10 02:22
推
04/10 02:26,
04/10 02:26
推
04/10 02:29,
04/10 02:29
推
04/10 02:54,
04/10 02:54
→
04/10 02:55,
04/10 02:55
推
04/10 03:04,
04/10 03:04
推
04/10 03:15,
04/10 03:15
→
04/10 03:15,
04/10 03:15
推
04/10 03:18,
04/10 03:18
→
04/10 03:41,
04/10 03:41
→
04/10 03:48,
04/10 03:48
→
04/10 03:50,
04/10 03:50
推
04/10 04:11,
04/10 04:11
推
04/10 05:14,
04/10 05:14
推
04/10 06:48,
04/10 06:48
→
04/10 06:49,
04/10 06:49
推
04/10 07:44,
04/10 07:44
→
04/10 08:36,
04/10 08:36
推
04/10 08:40,
04/10 08:40
推
04/10 09:03,
04/10 09:03
推
04/10 09:14,
04/10 09:14
推
04/10 09:55,
04/10 09:55
推
04/10 10:35,
04/10 10:35
推
04/10 11:03,
04/10 11:03
推
04/10 11:41,
04/10 11:41
推
04/10 12:13,
04/10 12:13
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 116.59.32.194
推
04/10 12:56, , 1F
04/10 12:56, 1F
推
04/10 17:44, , 2F
04/10 17:44, 2F
※ 編輯: s606051 來自: 116.59.105.120 (04/10 19:42)
→
04/10 19:43, , 3F
04/10 19:43, 3F
推
04/10 23:36, , 4F
04/10 23:36, 4F
推
04/12 11:33, , 5F
04/12 11:33, 5F
推
04/12 15:13, , 6F
04/12 15:13, 6F
→
04/12 19:21, , 7F
04/12 19:21, 7F
→
04/12 19:23, , 8F
04/12 19:23, 8F
→
04/12 19:23, , 9F
04/12 19:23, 9F
→
04/12 19:32, , 10F
04/12 19:32, 10F
推
04/13 02:32, , 11F
04/13 02:32, 11F
→
04/13 02:33, , 12F
04/13 02:33, 12F