Fw: [文法] 請問一題Azar官網PPT的題目

看板TOEIC作者 (仕倖)時間12年前 (2013/09/11 13:33), 編輯推噓3(3推 0噓 31→)
留言34則, 3人參與, 最新討論串1/1
※ [本文轉錄自 Eng-Class 看板 #1IC01UmS ] 作者: h10840206 (仕倖) 看板: Eng-Class 標題: [文法] 請問一題Azar官網PPT的題目 時間: Wed Sep 11 13:32:12 2013 Azar進階那本的官網教學PPT的題目(http://ppt.cc/6mf1) 網站下方Chapter 13形容詞子句PPT中，第13頁的下面那題多選題。 2. The Think Tank is the only place in the world ______ visitors have free access to this type of research. (a) who (b) that (c) which (d) x (e) where (f) when 他的答案是(d),(e)，為什麼呢？ 以下是我的想法： 用where比較沒有意外，我還OK。 但是為什麼可以省略我就不太懂了。 一般來說，出現the only等「明確指示地」修飾先行詞者， 其關係代名詞要用that一併指示， 若具有指示性且不影響結構，則可省略that(by 旋元佑文法)。 但這裡修飾的是地方名詞，而且從屬子句挺完整的， 所以關係詞不當受詞，故必須要有介系詞。 在Azar進階書中也提到「若不使用where時，則必須用介系詞」。 可是這題沒有介系詞呀？ have free access to的to已經接了後面的research了。 那為什麼這題答案會有(d)表可省略呢？ 請關係副詞大大詳解~~非常感謝@@ 無意中看到遇到瓶頸我怕又要砍掉重練... -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 118.160.44.84 ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ※ 轉錄者: h10840206 (118.160.44.84), 時間: 09/11/2013 13:33:09
推
09/11 19:27, , 1F
這題我也不會 我去翻找我的文法寶典才找到答案@@
09/11 19:27, 1F
→
09/11 19:27, , 2F
在一般情況下where不可用that代替 只有在先行詞為
09/11 19:27, 2F
→
09/11 19:34, , 3F
the place時 才可用that代替where或是省略 看來that
09/11 19:34, 3F
→
09/11 19:34, , 4F
好像也可以@@? 不知其他人有無意見可幫忙解答?
09/11 19:34, 4F
→
09/11 19:45, , 5F
that要留介系詞（Azar Advanced有寫）
09/11 19:45, 5F
推
09/12 01:35, , 6F
後來又問過老師 他說that也可以是正確答案之一
09/12 01:35, 6F
→
09/12 01:36, , 7F
that visitors have free access to this type of
09/12 01:36, 7F
→
09/12 01:36, , 8F
research 是名詞子句作為the only place in the
09/12 01:36, 8F
→
09/12 01:37, , 9F
world 的同位語，所以that可以省略 重點來了
09/12 01:37, 9F
→
09/12 01:38, , 10F
that可以省略的原因是因為同位語關係而不是
09/12 01:38, 10F
→
09/12 01:39, , 11F
關係代名詞的關係
09/12 01:39, 11F
→
09/12 08:32, , 12F
那這樣所有關係副詞不都可以變成that接的同位語
09/12 08:32, 12F
→
09/12 08:33, , 13F
跟關係子句無關？ 越搞越亂了@@
09/12 08:33, 13F
推
09/12 20:02, , 14F
1.答案若是where那原句是
09/12 20:02, 14F
→
09/12 20:02, , 15F
The Think Tank is the only place in the world
09/12 20:02, 15F
→
09/12 20:03, , 16F
that visitors have free access to this type of
09/12 20:03, 16F
→
09/12 20:03, , 17F
research at.
09/12 20:03, 17F
→
09/12 20:03, , 18F
= The Think Tank is the only place in the world
09/12 20:03, 18F
→
09/12 20:03, , 19F
at which visitors have free access to this type
09/12 20:03, 19F
→
09/12 20:04, , 20F
of research.
09/12 20:04, 20F
→
09/12 20:04, , 21F
=The Think Tank is the only place in the world
09/12 20:04, 21F
→
09/12 20:04, , 22F
where visitors have free access to this type
09/12 20:04, 22F
→
09/12 20:04, , 23F
of research.
09/12 20:04, 23F
→
09/12 20:05, , 24F
是關係子句(形容詞子句)修飾先行詞the only place
09/12 20:05, 24F
→
09/12 20:05, , 25F
in the world，where不能省略
09/12 20:05, 25F
→
09/12 20:05, , 26F
2.答案若是(X) 那原句是
09/12 20:05, 26F
→
09/12 20:05, , 27F
The Think Tank is the only place in the world
09/12 20:05, 27F
→
09/12 20:06, , 28F
that visitors have free access to this type
09/12 20:06, 28F
→
09/12 20:06, , 29F
of research. that visitors have free access to
09/12 20:06, 29F
→
09/12 20:06, , 30F
this type of research 是名詞子句作為the only
09/12 20:06, 30F
→
09/12 20:07, , 31F
place in the world 的同位語，所以that可以省略
09/12 20:07, 31F
→
09/12 20:07, , 32F
我複製得手好痠阿~"~ 希望你慢慢體會其含意
09/12 20:07, 32F
→
08/06 16:05, , 33F
that要留介系詞（A https://noxiv.com
08/06 16:05, 33F
→
09/07 02:28, , 34F
that要留介系詞（A https://daxiv.com
09/07 02:28, 34F
‣ 更多 h10840206 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1IC02Ntl (TOEIC)