[題目] Longman Advanced 4/e

看板TOEIC作者 (m(_ _)m)時間15年前 (2010/03/18 22:44), 編輯推噓3(3013)
留言16則, 6人參與, 最新討論串1/1
書名: 朗文 advanced 3 頁數:p221 題目:第151題 We have never before ____such a large order delivered to the wrong business with no trace of its whereabouts. a. had b. having c. have d. has 疑問: 答案是a, 但不是介系詞後面要加v-ing嗎?為什麼不能選b -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 114.47.72.26

03/18 22:49, , 1F
這裡的before是副詞~
03/18 22:49, 1F

03/18 22:52, , 2F
請問怎麼判斷阿0.0 如果是副詞的話,是形容had嗎?
03/18 22:52, 2F
※ 編輯: alaricblue 來自: 114.47.72.26 (03/18 22:56)

03/18 22:59, , 3F
可以想成before, we have never had such a...
03/18 22:59, 3F

03/18 23:02, , 4F
before當介詞前面要有完整句型結構,
03/18 23:02, 4F

03/18 23:03, , 5F
這裡we have的have並不是動詞,動詞在後面另一個have
03/18 23:03, 5F

03/18 23:04, , 6F
我是靠語感的 解釋的很爛 有說錯還請指正...
03/18 23:04, 6F

03/19 11:19, , 7F
我覺得是before不看而用現在完成式(但我也是靠語感
03/19 11:19, 7F

03/19 12:19, , 8F
從文法來看的話,have如果當「有」來看,必有受詞
03/19 12:19, 8F

03/19 12:19, , 9F
但是這邊having當受詞是不合理的
03/19 12:19, 9F

03/19 12:20, , 10F
所以可以逆推前面的have是助動詞,所以這個空格就要
03/19 12:20, 10F

03/19 12:20, , 11F
填上pp
03/19 12:20, 11F

03/19 14:11, , 12F
而且也沒有have having這種東西吧= =...
03/19 14:11, 12F

03/19 14:13, , 13F
never before在這是做形容詞片語~他是來修飾的
03/19 14:13, 13F

03/19 14:14, , 14F
你試著把never before拿掉~~在去看句子~一下就懂了
03/19 14:14, 14F

03/19 16:13, , 15F
喔喔 懂了~被never before干擾騙了QQ
03/19 16:13, 15F

03/20 00:52, , 16F
have是完成式
03/20 00:52, 16F
文章代碼(AID): #1BeZn0Z6 (TOEIC)