[心得] 星光五積分賽的內容總評
趁著冠軍賽結束後來講一下我對這四場積分賽的感覺
我覺得對於很多從星光一或星光二開始看的觀眾來說可能會覺得少了一些東西
在主題上 這屆少了一些以往星光好看的主題
例如 偶像合唱抗壓賽
老戰友合唱賽(感覺之前的十強至六強的主題淘汰賽應該出現)
天堂HIGH歌地獄悲歌挑戰賽
自我突破挑戰賽
老歌新唱挑戰賽
我個人是覺得少了偶像合唱抗壓賽比其他四項來的可惜
再來看一下這四場積分賽的內容
1 指定PK賽:我覺得這場很不必要
因為積分賽應該是選手唱兩首歌
加上PK者感覺很怪
要PK選手來的話應該是出現在資格決定賽
這場應該換成 偶像合唱抗賽或歌手合唱賽
製作單位大概是想學超3的積分賽
但是其實不適當
2 我的演唱會: 這場還不錯 不過如果能像更逼真的演唱會
應該要兩首連著唱
畢竟正式演唱會不會間隔這麼長
3 K歌金曲挑戰賽: 我覺得這集的主題不是很好
感覺也比較沒意義
跟平常主題太像了
而且第一輪抽三首挑一首 感覺有點扯
這樣有點比籤運
這集如果換成天堂地獄 老戰友 或是自我突破挑戰賽
應該比較好
4 歌中劇 :這場沒有甚麼缺點 這個主題有創新 而且很好看
在主題上 有幾場的主題 看的出製作單位有新意
但是上述的1 跟3 真的不是很恰當
用舊主題應該會比較好
另外 偶像合唱抗壓賽其實已經是星光的招牌主題了
積分賽應該要有這個主題
以上是我的小小的淺見
不知道大家的想法如何
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 220.136.226.49
推
10/14 23:11, , 1F
10/14 23:11, 1F
→
10/14 23:11, , 2F
10/14 23:11, 2F
推
10/14 23:11, , 3F
10/14 23:11, 3F
→
10/14 23:11, , 4F
10/14 23:11, 4F
→
10/14 23:12, , 5F
10/14 23:12, 5F
→
10/14 23:12, , 6F
10/14 23:12, 6F
→
10/14 23:12, , 7F
10/14 23:12, 7F
→
10/14 23:12, , 8F
10/14 23:12, 8F
→
10/14 23:12, , 9F
10/14 23:12, 9F
→
10/14 23:12, , 10F
10/14 23:12, 10F
→
10/14 23:12, , 11F
10/14 23:12, 11F
推
10/14 23:13, , 12F
10/14 23:13, 12F
→
10/14 23:13, , 13F
10/14 23:13, 13F
→
10/14 23:13, , 14F
10/14 23:13, 14F
→
10/14 23:14, , 15F
10/14 23:14, 15F
→
10/14 23:14, , 16F
10/14 23:14, 16F
→
10/14 23:14, , 17F
10/14 23:14, 17F
→
10/14 23:14, , 18F
10/14 23:14, 18F
推
10/14 23:15, , 19F
10/14 23:15, 19F
→
10/14 23:16, , 20F
10/14 23:16, 20F
→
10/14 23:16, , 21F
10/14 23:16, 21F
推
10/14 23:16, , 22F
10/14 23:16, 22F
→
10/14 23:16, , 23F
10/14 23:16, 23F
→
10/14 23:17, , 24F
10/14 23:17, 24F
→
10/14 23:17, , 25F
10/14 23:17, 25F
推
10/14 23:17, , 26F
10/14 23:17, 26F
→
10/14 23:17, , 27F
10/14 23:17, 27F
→
10/14 23:17, , 28F
10/14 23:17, 28F
→
10/14 23:17, , 29F
10/14 23:17, 29F
→
10/14 23:17, , 30F
10/14 23:17, 30F
→
10/14 23:18, , 31F
10/14 23:18, 31F
→
10/14 23:18, , 32F
10/14 23:18, 32F
→
10/14 23:18, , 33F
10/14 23:18, 33F
→
10/14 23:18, , 34F
10/14 23:18, 34F
推
10/14 23:18, , 35F
10/14 23:18, 35F
→
10/14 23:18, , 36F
10/14 23:18, 36F
→
10/14 23:20, , 37F
10/14 23:20, 37F
→
10/14 23:21, , 38F
10/14 23:21, 38F
推
10/14 23:22, , 39F
10/14 23:22, 39F
→
10/14 23:22, , 40F
10/14 23:22, 40F
推
10/14 23:22, , 41F
10/14 23:22, 41F
推
10/14 23:22, , 42F
10/14 23:22, 42F
→
10/14 23:24, , 43F
10/14 23:24, 43F
推
10/14 23:24, , 44F
10/14 23:24, 44F
→
10/14 23:25, , 45F
10/14 23:25, 45F
→
10/14 23:26, , 46F
10/14 23:26, 46F
推
10/14 23:26, , 47F
10/14 23:26, 47F
→
10/14 23:27, , 48F
10/14 23:27, 48F
→
10/14 23:27, , 49F
10/14 23:27, 49F
→
10/14 23:27, , 50F
10/14 23:27, 50F
→
10/14 23:27, , 51F
10/14 23:27, 51F
→
10/14 23:28, , 52F
10/14 23:28, 52F
→
10/14 23:28, , 53F
10/14 23:28, 53F
→
10/14 23:28, , 54F
10/14 23:28, 54F
→
10/14 23:29, , 55F
10/14 23:29, 55F
→
10/14 23:29, , 56F
10/14 23:29, 56F
→
10/14 23:30, , 57F
10/14 23:30, 57F
→
10/14 23:30, , 58F
10/14 23:30, 58F
→
10/14 23:30, , 59F
10/14 23:30, 59F
→
10/14 23:30, , 60F
10/14 23:30, 60F
→
10/14 23:33, , 61F
10/14 23:33, 61F
→
10/14 23:33, , 62F
10/14 23:33, 62F
→
10/14 23:33, , 63F
10/14 23:33, 63F
→
10/14 23:34, , 64F
10/14 23:34, 64F
推
10/14 23:35, , 65F
10/14 23:35, 65F
→
10/15 00:48, , 66F
10/15 00:48, 66F
→
10/15 00:49, , 67F
10/15 00:49, 67F
→
10/15 00:49, , 68F
10/15 00:49, 68F
→
10/15 00:50, , 69F
10/15 00:50, 69F
→
01/16 18:47,
5年前
, 70F
01/16 18:47, 70F