[問題] David K. Cheng的一段文字

看板Physics作者 (雞爪)時間9年前 (2014/11/27 00:48), 編輯推噓0(003)
留言3則, 2人參與, 最新討論串1/1
David K. Cheng第二版電磁學的第632~633頁,為了證明天線的reciprocity property, 將天線A和天線B的發送及接收電路化,化為線性的two-port network V1 = Z11* I1 + Z12*I2 V2 = Z21* I1 + Z22*I2 而之後有段文字如下: When the medium in the transmission path between antennas A and B is bilateral such that reciprocity relations hold, the transfer or coupling impedances Z12 and Z21 are equal. Under normal circumstances, transmitting and receiving antennas are separated by very large distances, and the coupling impedances are negligibly small as far as the reaction on the transmitting antenna owing to scattering by the receiving antenna is concerned. In the limit r→∞, lim Z12 = 0 r→∞ 我的問題是...這邊寫道,當兩個天線距離很遠時,兩者間的阻抗趨近於零?? why? 不是應該因為距離變遠的關係而更大嗎? 煩請版上高手為小弟解惑,謝謝 --               / ̄ ̄ ̄ ㄟ |   |            /     ㄟ |    |               |   (> )( <) < XD  |             | /// (_人_) |    |            |    \__/ ! |    |             |      ㄟ \____| -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 218.161.71.11 ※ 文章網址: http://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Physics/M.1417020517.A.F2E.html

11/29 10:50, , 1F
應該只是用[Z]來比擬 不是真的有阻抗的意義
11/29 10:50, 1F

11/29 10:52, , 2F
這段文字的描述 感覺就直覺表示很遠時候兩者沒有關係 場為0
11/29 10:52, 2F

11/29 16:20, , 3F
謝謝樓上
11/29 16:20, 3F
文章代碼(AID): #1KTWHbyk (Physics)