[期刊] International Journal of Hydrogen Energy
投稿期刊: International Journal of Hydrogen Energy
投稿日誌: 3/20 initial, 3/27 with editor & given manuscript number,
4/29 decision: revise
文章工作經過: 此文章前後修改了半年, 在格式上, data數量上和自我一致性老師皆比較
要求, 希望能一次被審過. 個人則覺得自己在introduction寫得比較生動.
Reviewer #1: The work is well ordered and written. I consider that manuscript
could be published after some minor revisions. (他叫我改圖片配色)
Reviewer #2: In principle, this Reviewer does not have objections to the
publication of this manuscript in its current form. It is relatively well
written and full of data.
Editor: I am pleased to inform you that your manuscript received positive
feedback from the reviewers. …I ask that the authors have a qualified English
language reviewer carefully proofread and correct the manuscript for
grammatical and stylistic errors.
心得: 這篇文章可能因為字數很多(約10000字), 因為怕看的人頭昏, 所以修得比較小心.
這次的經驗令我覺得文章的表面(英文, 陳述順序, 有無type error)很重要, 讓人找不到
你的毛病, 看得很順的話, reviewer好像自然就不會質疑你scientific上的問題. 還有
Introduction是否能引人入勝也是相當重要的事. 昨天打開信箱有點驚到, 因為此期刊的
審稿週期平均半年, 一開始還在想是不是八成GG了, ORz…
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.43.4.6
※ 編輯: cssula 來自: 114.43.4.6 (05/01 08:00)