[新聞] What went wrong with TEoG mv
What went wrong with GaGa's 'Edge of Glory' video?
NY post
http://tinyurl.com/3w562vf
重點提要:
1.Joseph Kahn在推特上否認這是他的作品,主因是拍攝過程中gaga及haus of
gaga開始七嘴八舌推翻他的想法,所以最後他退出,也就是說gaga才是這支mv的導演
2. Kahn的團隊本來已經搭好了set:
http://i51.tinypic.com/vrzfo8.jpg
內容有布魯克林橋、醫院、水底景等...也就是原本的人魚路線
3. 編舞Laurieann Gibson在推特上回應小怪獸對MV的批評(演變成大吵),認為創作想法
分歧是常有的是,小怪獸不應這麼刻薄
個人感想:Joseph Kahn的作品多麼厲害大家可以去孤看看,基本上我覺得嘎及嘎屋請
了名導又不信任他是很愚蠢的事情,尤其當最後完全照自己點子拍出來的東西這麼貽笑
大方
在TFM時我還不覺得,但現在我認為the fame is kinda getting to her head,也就是大
頭症。
太快了。
Lady GaGa's videos are opulent affairs thanks to complex storylines,
extravagant costume changes, an army of back-up dancers showcasing the latest
moves from genius choreographer Laurieann Gibson and visually dazzling
screenshots that could hang in any respectable art gallery.
But when her latest music video for "Edge of Glory" premiered last night, the
general consensus was "huh?" As in, "what the hell is this pared down,
choreography-deficient, one costume, dancer-free piece of rubbish?"
At first, fans leapt to judgement and began harassing Joseph Kahn, the
visionary director who has helmed videos for artists like U2, Britney, Mariah,
Snoop. He also was the man behind "Edge of Glory." Emphasis on "was."
Yesterday he Tweeted, "I did NOT direct Lady Gaga's 'Edge of Glory' video.
Lady Gaga did -- I don't co-direct. One canvas, one paintbrush. Respect the
art. Very simple rule with me."
This seemed to imply disagreements on the set, a theory that has been
corroborated by Joseph's team, sources close to production and, well,
watching the video.
One such insider, Chancler Haynes (Kahn's on-set editor), revealed on Twitter
exactly what went down in a series of DM's with a fan ... who then released the
conversation.
It seems that the mermaid motif GaGa debuted on "Le Grand Journal" was supposed
to be the video's theme as well. "[Joseph Kahn] had sets built for a hospital
scene, Brooklyn Bridge, and a big underwater mermaid scene. It all made sense.
Concept was done," Chancler wrote.
But somewhere along the way there was, to hear Laurieann tell it, "an issue."
One that, according to Chancler, stemmed straight from The Haus of GaGa. "GaGa
changed her mind and told Joseph what to do. His hands were tied. The director
just didn't have control over GaGa after she started making changes [and]
Joseph's concept died."
A concept that according to three leaked production stills (which Chancler
confirmed to be real) looked suitably epic.
If only the drama stopped there. Last night, after the underwhelming video made
its grand debut, her Little Monsters proved just how sharp their claws are and
began Tweet-tacking Laurieann on Twitter. NBD, this happens all the time when
you participate in an open dialogue with fans. The difference here is that
Laurieann returned fire when one fan accused her of stretching the truth.
"listen u disrespectful f**k they had an issue on set I don't lie!!!!!" Her
140 character verbal vomit also included, "creative Changes happen always
educate ignorant Monster's!!!" She then went on and personally responded to
two dozen angry comments that varied from "you r sick Get some help u have no
clue" to "who r u!!! don't talk negative to people u don't know it's foolish!"
And that seems to be the buzz word here since foolishness reigned from start
to finish. It was foolish of GaGa's team to stop trusting the director they
hired, it was foolish of GaGa to think this subdued video would please the fans
that have been conditioned to expect something grander, it was foolish of
Chancler to have that conversation online and it was foolish of Laurieann to
open fire on fans.
But most of all, it was foolish of us to expect that GaGa would never stumble
because, despite the preternatural image constantly presented, she is only
human after all.
http://tinyurl.com/3w562vf
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 58.114.208.60
推
06/17 23:35, , 1F
06/17 23:35, 1F
推
06/17 23:36, , 2F
06/17 23:36, 2F
推
06/17 23:37, , 3F
06/17 23:37, 3F
→
06/17 23:38, , 4F
06/17 23:38, 4F
推
06/17 23:38, , 5F
06/17 23:38, 5F
→
06/17 23:40, , 6F
06/17 23:40, 6F
推
06/17 23:41, , 7F
06/17 23:41, 7F
推
06/17 23:47, , 8F
06/17 23:47, 8F
→
06/17 23:48, , 9F
06/17 23:48, 9F
推
06/17 23:49, , 10F
06/17 23:49, 10F
推
06/17 23:55, , 11F
06/17 23:55, 11F
→
06/17 23:56, , 12F
06/17 23:56, 12F
推
06/17 23:58, , 13F
06/17 23:58, 13F
推
06/17 23:59, , 14F
06/17 23:59, 14F
→
06/17 23:59, , 15F
06/17 23:59, 15F
推
06/18 00:06, , 16F
06/18 00:06, 16F
推
06/18 00:06, , 17F
06/18 00:06, 17F
推
06/18 00:08, , 18F
06/18 00:08, 18F
→
06/18 00:09, , 19F
06/18 00:09, 19F
推
06/18 00:15, , 20F
06/18 00:15, 20F
→
06/18 00:15, , 21F
06/18 00:15, 21F
推
06/18 00:15, , 22F
06/18 00:15, 22F
推
06/18 00:24, , 23F
06/18 00:24, 23F
推
06/18 00:27, , 24F
06/18 00:27, 24F
→
06/18 00:28, , 25F
06/18 00:28, 25F
推
06/18 00:37, , 26F
06/18 00:37, 26F
推
06/18 01:17, , 27F
06/18 01:17, 27F
→
06/18 01:18, , 28F
06/18 01:18, 28F
→
06/18 01:22, , 29F
06/18 01:22, 29F
推
06/18 01:23, , 30F
06/18 01:23, 30F
→
06/18 01:24, , 31F
06/18 01:24, 31F
推
06/18 01:36, , 32F
06/18 01:36, 32F
→
06/18 01:36, , 33F
06/18 01:36, 33F
推
06/18 01:59, , 34F
06/18 01:59, 34F
推
06/18 02:17, , 35F
06/18 02:17, 35F
推
06/18 03:12, , 36F
06/18 03:12, 36F
→
06/18 03:13, , 37F
06/18 03:13, 37F
→
06/18 04:16, , 38F
06/18 04:16, 38F
推
06/18 08:25, , 39F
06/18 08:25, 39F
→
06/18 08:26, , 40F
06/18 08:26, 40F
推
06/18 10:11, , 41F
06/18 10:11, 41F
→
06/18 10:11, , 42F
06/18 10:11, 42F
推
06/18 10:29, , 43F
06/18 10:29, 43F
推
06/18 10:32, , 44F
06/18 10:32, 44F
→
06/18 10:33, , 45F
06/18 10:33, 45F
→
06/18 10:34, , 46F
06/18 10:34, 46F
→
06/18 10:35, , 47F
06/18 10:35, 47F
→
06/18 10:35, , 48F
06/18 10:35, 48F
推
06/18 11:08, , 49F
06/18 11:08, 49F
推
06/18 11:09, , 50F
06/18 11:09, 50F
推
06/18 13:43, , 51F
06/18 13:43, 51F
→
06/18 13:43, , 52F
06/18 13:43, 52F
推
06/18 14:14, , 53F
06/18 14:14, 53F
→
06/18 14:15, , 54F
06/18 14:15, 54F
→
06/18 14:16, , 55F
06/18 14:16, 55F
推
06/18 15:00, , 56F
06/18 15:00, 56F
→
06/18 15:01, , 57F
06/18 15:01, 57F
→
06/18 15:01, , 58F
06/18 15:01, 58F
推
06/18 15:42, , 59F
06/18 15:42, 59F
推
06/18 17:03, , 60F
06/18 17:03, 60F
推
06/18 23:35, , 61F
06/18 23:35, 61F
推
06/21 05:36, , 62F
06/21 05:36, 62F
→
06/21 12:37, , 63F
06/21 12:37, 63F
推
06/21 19:14, , 64F
06/21 19:14, 64F
→
06/21 19:15, , 65F
06/21 19:15, 65F
→
06/21 19:15, , 66F
06/21 19:15, 66F