[討教] 金庸的打狗棒與鄭丰的打狗棒
在金庸小說裡 丐幫有兩大武功
一是降龍十八掌 另一是打狗棒法
其中打狗棒法更只傳後任幫主 絕不傳第二人
這大家都知道 我就不囉嗦了
最近在因緣際會之下 重讀了鄭丰的靈劍以及天關雙俠
裡面寫到丐幫幫主吳三石也會打狗棒法
而且也是用「巧」來擊退對手
兩種的打狗棒都是丐幫的寶物 見到打狗棒視同見到幫主
鄭丰號稱女版金庸
想當然也是被金庸給引響到
想請問
1.打狗棒法是否為金庸原創，還是原本丐幫就有這東西?
2.鄭丰小說裡的打狗棒法跟金庸是否很類似
3.兩種打夠棒是不是長的一樣
4.鄭丰寫小說創了不少絕招 但為何偏偏要留一個打狗棒法
--
沉醉東風﹒漁夫
白樸
黃蘆岸白蘋渡口，綠楊堤紅蓼灘頭。
雖無刎頸交，卻有忘機友。
點秋江白鷺沙鷗。傲殺人間萬戶侯，不識字煙波釣叟。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 123.192.217.58
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/JinYong/M.1428502779.A.F01.html
→
04/08 23:00, , 1F
04/08 23:00, 1F
→
04/08 23:04, , 2F
04/08 23:04, 2F
→
04/09 00:03, , 3F
04/09 00:03, 3F
推
04/09 00:25, , 4F
04/09 00:25, 4F
→
04/09 00:26, , 5F
04/09 00:26, 5F
→
04/09 00:27, , 6F
04/09 00:27, 6F
→
04/09 09:35, , 7F
04/09 09:35, 7F
→
04/09 11:09, , 8F
04/09 11:09, 8F
推
04/09 18:21, , 9F
04/09 18:21, 9F
→
04/09 20:14, , 10F
04/09 20:14, 10F
推
04/09 21:13, , 11F
04/09 21:13, 11F
→
04/10 00:51, , 12F
04/10 00:51, 12F
→
04/10 00:52, , 13F
04/10 00:52, 13F
→
04/10 00:53, , 14F
04/10 00:53, 14F
→
04/10 00:54, , 15F
04/10 00:54, 15F
→
04/10 00:57, , 16F
04/10 00:57, 16F
→
04/10 00:58, , 17F
04/10 00:58, 17F
→
04/10 00:59, , 18F
04/10 00:59, 18F
→
04/10 01:00, , 19F
04/10 01:00, 19F
→
04/10 01:01, , 20F
04/10 01:01, 20F
→
04/10 01:02, , 21F
04/10 01:02, 21F
推
04/10 01:06, , 22F
04/10 01:06, 22F
→
04/10 01:07, , 23F
04/10 01:07, 23F
→
04/10 01:09, , 24F
04/10 01:09, 24F
推
04/10 01:18, , 25F
04/10 01:18, 25F
推
04/10 11:26, , 26F
04/10 11:26, 26F
推
04/10 12:09, , 27F
04/10 12:09, 27F
→
04/10 12:22, , 28F
04/10 12:22, 28F
推
04/10 17:49, , 29F
04/10 17:49, 29F
→
05/03 22:30, , 30F
05/03 22:30, 30F
→
05/03 22:30, , 31F
05/03 22:30, 31F
推
05/05 13:44, , 32F
05/05 13:44, 32F
→
05/05 13:44, , 33F
05/05 13:44, 33F
推
08/19 00:02, , 34F
08/19 00:02, 34F
推
05/10 01:41, , 35F
05/10 01:41, 35F
→
05/10 01:41, , 36F
05/10 01:41, 36F