[討教] 倪匡的天龍八部
小弟是金庸版的潛水迷
最近又重看了一次天龍八部
突然又想到倪匡曾經幫這部作品代筆
查了一下版上以前的文章
又上網google了一下代筆的部分是那些章節
http://www.wiselypuzzle.com/introduction/story/ghostwritesummary.html
想問有板友有代筆的部分的電子檔可以參考嗎?
大家都說倪匡把金老的整盤架構跟思路打亂了
從我查到的網頁來看~ 差比較多的是
(1)波羅星騎蛇搶經(2)慕容復對段譽的好感
(3)段譽以「朱蛤神功」與游坦之的「冰蠶毒掌」對打這幾段
不知道看過倪匡版本跟後來改版的朋友，有沒有什麼見解呢?
倪匡的代寫真的把天龍八部寫爛了嗎? 還是讓它變成一本更科幻的小說?
因為也有人說 天山童老反老還童也是倪匡寫的~阿朱也是他殺的等等
因為我沒看過連載版本所以也無從考證~~
附上金庸與倪匡對答的網路笑話
http://sleepywoods.blog.163.com/blog/static/171102837200662411854513/
--
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.116.53.114
→
06/18 11:55, , 1F
06/18 11:55, 1F
→
06/18 11:55, , 2F
06/18 11:55, 2F
推
06/18 12:14, , 3F
06/18 12:14, 3F
推
06/18 12:15, , 4F
06/18 12:15, 4F
推
06/18 12:43, , 5F
06/18 12:43, 5F
推
06/18 12:52, , 6F
06/18 12:52, 6F
推
06/18 13:01, , 7F
06/18 13:01, 7F
→
06/18 13:02, , 8F
06/18 13:02, 8F
→
06/18 13:02, , 9F
06/18 13:02, 9F
→
06/18 13:03, , 10F
06/18 13:03, 10F
→
06/18 13:04, , 11F
06/18 13:04, 11F
推
06/18 13:16, , 12F
06/18 13:16, 12F
→
06/18 13:16, , 13F
06/18 13:16, 13F
→
06/18 13:16, , 14F
06/18 13:16, 14F
→
06/18 13:16, , 15F
06/18 13:16, 15F
→
06/18 13:16, , 16F
06/18 13:16, 16F
→
06/18 13:16, , 17F
06/18 13:16, 17F
→
06/18 13:16, , 18F
06/18 13:16, 18F
→
06/18 13:16, , 19F
06/18 13:16, 19F
→
06/18 13:16, , 20F
06/18 13:16, 20F
→
06/18 13:16, , 21F
06/18 13:16, 21F
→
06/18 13:16, , 22F
06/18 13:16, 22F
→
06/18 13:16, , 23F
06/18 13:16, 23F
→
06/18 13:17, , 24F
06/18 13:17, 24F
推
06/18 13:19, , 25F
06/18 13:19, 25F
推
06/21 15:29, , 26F
06/21 15:29, 26F
推
01/26 08:44, , 27F
01/26 08:44, 27F