[閒聊] 近年來翻拍經典的港片有超越前部的嗎
近年來有不少翻拍經典的港片,可是似乎沒
有一部能超越前者,連平起平做都很勉強,
以下我舉三者為例:
李連杰的黃飛鴻VS彭于晏的英雄有夢
張國榮 王祖賢的倩女幽魂VS新倩女幽魂
新龍門客棧VS龍門飛甲
上述三部的翻拍片,個人感覺真的連勉強
並駕其驅都很難,更不用說超越前者,而且
上述三部的翻拍還算好的,看看慘不忍睹
的急凍行者,還有挑這三部經典來討論,也
是因為這三部經典也是翻拍更早的,但都
與前作並行甚至更好,為何近年來的翻拍
無法超越呢?
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 42.72.53.10
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/HK-movie/M.1467784543.A.E82.html
推
07/06 14:02, , 1F
07/06 14:02, 1F
→
07/06 15:11, , 2F
07/06 15:11, 2F
推
07/06 15:26, , 3F
07/06 15:26, 3F
推
07/06 15:40, , 4F
07/06 15:40, 4F
→
07/06 15:40, , 5F
07/06 15:40, 5F
推
07/06 15:56, , 6F
07/06 15:56, 6F
推
07/06 16:12, , 7F
07/06 16:12, 7F
推
07/06 17:00, , 8F
07/06 17:00, 8F
→
07/06 18:38, , 9F
07/06 18:38, 9F
推
07/06 19:28, , 10F
07/06 19:28, 10F
推
07/06 20:08, , 11F
07/06 20:08, 11F
推
07/06 23:33, , 12F
07/06 23:33, 12F
推
07/06 23:37, , 13F
07/06 23:37, 13F
→
07/07 00:17, , 14F
07/07 00:17, 14F
→
07/07 10:37, , 15F
07/07 10:37, 15F
→
07/07 10:38, , 16F
07/07 10:38, 16F
推
07/07 11:06, , 17F
07/07 11:06, 17F
推
07/07 11:16, , 18F
07/07 11:16, 18F
推
07/07 20:49, , 19F
07/07 20:49, 19F
→
07/07 20:50, , 20F
07/07 20:50, 20F
→
07/09 00:27, , 21F
07/09 00:27, 21F
→
07/09 00:28, , 22F
07/09 00:28, 22F
推
07/09 10:52, , 23F
07/09 10:52, 23F
推
07/09 22:25, , 24F
07/09 22:25, 24F
→
07/11 00:06, , 25F
07/11 00:06, 25F
→
07/12 04:25, , 26F
07/12 04:25, 26F
推
07/13 13:07, , 27F
07/13 13:07, 27F
推
07/16 01:03, , 28F
07/16 01:03, 28F
→
07/26 23:06, , 29F
07/26 23:06, 29F