[討論] Sarah's Take: Relief not so hard to find
Sarah's Take: Relief not so hard to find
07/19/2008 6:45 PM ET
By Sarah D. Morris / Special to Dodgers.com
Last week I was writing about the Dodgers' pitching because I felt good
about it. Then, last Saturday against the Florida Marlins, Takashi Saito
injured his elbow. Now the Dodgers don't have an established closer, and I
don't feel as good about the Dodgers' pitching situation as I did.
Going into the All-Star break, the Dodgers had the lowest ERA in the
National League. In the series with the Atlanta Braves a week before the
break, Derek Lowe, Hiroki Kuroda, and Chad Billingsley didn't allow a hit
until the fifth inning or later. Although the Dodgers don't have Brad
Penny in the starting rotation, they have arguably the best starting
rotation in the NL West.
Since Opening Day, the Dodgers' bullpen has done an excellent job. The
Dodgers' bullpen has had the second lowest ERA in the league. It has been
a rarity that the Dodgers' bullpen has blown a lead. Although the Dodgers'
bullpen has suffered injuries to main relievers, the replacements have
filled in nicely.
However, Saito has been the closer throughout 2008. At times, he has
struggled during this season, which has been uncharacteristic for him as a
Dodger. The Dodgers always knew that they had an experienced closer, and I
was confident when the Dodgers had a lead in an important game that Saito
would preserve the lead.
Now Saito will be out for at least six weeks with a sprained ligament in
his right elbow. According to Saito, surgery is not out of the question if
the elbow doesn't respond to treatment. Although Saito may be back for
September, he might have thrown his last pitch this season. When the
injury happened, I was worried if he might have thrown his last pitch
ever. At 38, Saito might have called it quits if he needed Tommy John
elbow ligament replacement surgery, because rehab takes a year to 18
months. Although Saito loves playing baseball for the Dodgers, he misses
his family in Japan.
I enjoy watching Saito close games. Yes, some closers are more dominating,
but they don't have the variety of pitches and pinpoint control that Saito
has when he is right. I love to see his excitement when he successfully
closes a victory.
Now the Dodgers must live without Saito, at least until September.
Although the Dodgers had a disappointing and injury-riddled first half of
the season, they are within a game of the lead of the NL West. They will
play the Arizona Diamondbacks 12 more times this season. Since the D-backs
have come down to earth after having an excellent beginning to the season,
I feel the Dodgers can catch and pass them.
Without a reliable closer, I doubt the Dodgers will reach the pinnacle of
the NL West. With two weeks before the Trade Deadline, I don't see Ned
Colletti obtaining an experienced closer. This season, many teams have had
problems with their closers, and I believe getting a reliable closer will
be a top priority for these teams. The Dodgers have other, more important
needs than finding a replacement for Saito.
Since Jonathan Broxton has been a Dodger, the club has been grooming him
for a closing job. From 2006, Broxton had many opportunities to close
games, and he didn't do well. He has an awesome fastball and a good
slider. Before the All-Star break, Broxton was clocked throwing his
fastball at 100 mph. This makes him dominating, and every baseball team
wants a dominating closer.
Although I know Broxton might have the stuff to be a wonderful closer, I
don't know if he has the proper mental makeup. It takes a different mental
makeup to close a victory than to pitch the eighth. Broxton seems like a
quiet, unassuming man, and I don't think he has the superior confidence to
close. At times this season, Broxton has struggled with his control, and
has fallen in love with his slider, which made him ineffective. Maybe
later in his career, Broxton will be an excellent closer, but at 24, I
have to wonder whether Broxton is ready for the high-pressure role.
Then again, on Friday night, Broxton pitched a perfect 11th to preserve
the important victory that enabled the Dodgers to move into a first-place
tie with the D-backs.
The Dodgers must find an excellent closer within the organization. They
have many options.
I would like to see Joe Beimel as the closer, but he is one of two
left-handed pitchers in the Dodger bullpen, and he is needed in that role.
He has the mental makeup to be the closer. He wants to pitch every day and
this is important for a closer. Last season when Saito couldn't pitch,
Beimel successfully closed many wins.
I know Brian Falkenborg began the season in Las Vegas, but he was the
closer there. Since he has been a Dodger, he has been fantastic.
If Hong-Chih Kuo hadn't had five arm surgeries, he would be the perfect
choice. He is dominating. This season he has been marvelous. He knows he
can get anyone out. However, risking his health and his future ability to
pitch isn't worth having him close this season.
To me, Chan Ho Park can be an excellent closer. After struggling many
years in Texas and elsewhere, due to injuries, Park has been amazing for
the Dodgers. This season it has been a rarity when Park has pitched
poorly. He has dominating pitches.
In the first half, pitching, especially relief pitching, has been one of
the Dodgers' strengths. Although the Dodgers have had injuries to their
pitching staff, they still have had good pitching. The injury to Saito has
put the Dodgers' bullpen in disarray. It will be interesting to see how
the Dodgers respond to their latest challenge.
--
___ ___
/| | /\__\
|:| | ___ /:/ _/_
|:| | /\__\ /:/ /\__\
__|:|__| /:/__/ /:/ /:/ _/_
/::::\__\_____ /::\ \ /:/_/:/ /\__\
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 219.84.29.27
推
07/20 09:15, , 1F
07/20 09:15, 1F
推
07/20 09:26, , 2F
07/20 09:26, 2F
推
07/20 10:11, , 3F
07/20 10:11, 3F
推
07/20 10:17, , 4F
07/20 10:17, 4F
→
07/20 10:17, , 5F
07/20 10:17, 5F
推
07/20 10:21, , 6F
07/20 10:21, 6F
推
07/20 10:26, , 7F
07/20 10:26, 7F
推
07/20 11:19, , 8F
07/20 11:19, 8F
→
07/20 11:22, , 9F
07/20 11:22, 9F
推
07/20 11:41, , 10F
07/20 11:41, 10F
推
07/20 11:48, , 11F
07/20 11:48, 11F
推
07/21 02:05, , 12F
07/21 02:05, 12F