[爆卦] 揭開反法庭直播者的謊言!
我看了一下反法庭直播者振振有詞拿出來的條文,
也就是"聯邦訴訟條例"(FEDERAL RULES OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE)
第五十三條,條文的內容是這樣規定的:
Except as otherwise provided by a statute or these rules,
the court must not permit the taking of photographs in the courtroom
during judicial proceedings or the broadcasting of judicial pro-
ceedings from the courtroom.
大家看到了嗎?
上面第一就寫"除非另有法令規定,否則司法流程禁止轉播",
那麼,有沒有"另外的法令"規定呢?
很不好意思,是有的。
美國法院制定了一個"轉播條例"(Audio Streaming Pilot),
規定說"合乎公眾利益"的法庭狀況可以轉播:
https://tinyurl.com/yxfxjxsp
這個條文一開始就寫得很清楚:
Approved district courts, bankruptcy courts,
the U.S. Court of Federal Claims, and the U.S. Court of International
Trade participated in a pilot program to livestream audio of certain
proceedings involving matters of public interest.
"有涉及公眾利益者可以轉播"
那啥又是"公眾利益"呢?
條例寫得很清楚,主要如下:
a claim that, once resolved,
may impact the public or a discernable group of people
(e.g., employees, residents of a city or state, consumers);
a case raising issues of public health or safety;
a case involving a civil rights claim;
a case involving a public entity, agency, or official;
a case that has received media attention.
1. 對公眾產生衝擊的訴案
2. 攸關公眾健康與安全的訴案
3. 牽扯民權的訴案
4. 牽扯進政府當局的訴案
5. 引發媒體關注的訴案
以上五點都是可以聲請直播的案例,
所以那些人拿著聯邦訴訟法第五十三條出來說話,完全是騙人不懂的說法。
我想他們都是博士、英文應該也都比我一個英文翻譯好,
那他們為什麼要騙人,我就不明白了。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 122.100.75.188 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1749538444.A.4EB.html
→
06/10 14:54,
1周前
, 1F
06/10 14:54, 1F
推
06/10 14:55,
1周前
, 2F
06/10 14:55, 2F
→
06/10 14:55,
1周前
, 3F
06/10 14:55, 3F
→
06/10 14:55,
1周前
, 4F
06/10 14:55, 4F
噓
06/10 14:55,
1周前
, 5F
06/10 14:55, 5F
推
06/10 14:55,
1周前
, 6F
06/10 14:55, 6F
推
06/10 14:55,
1周前
, 7F
06/10 14:55, 7F
→
06/10 14:55,
1周前
, 8F
06/10 14:55, 8F
推
06/10 14:55,
1周前
, 9F
06/10 14:55, 9F
推
06/10 14:56,
1周前
, 10F
06/10 14:56, 10F
推
06/10 14:56,
1周前
, 11F
06/10 14:56, 11F
→
06/10 14:56,
1周前
, 12F
06/10 14:56, 12F
推
06/10 14:56,
1周前
, 13F
06/10 14:56, 13F
推
06/10 14:56,
1周前
, 14F
06/10 14:56, 14F
→
06/10 14:56,
1周前
, 15F
06/10 14:56, 15F
→
06/10 14:57,
1周前
, 16F
06/10 14:57, 16F
推
06/10 14:57,
1周前
, 17F
06/10 14:57, 17F
噓
06/10 14:57,
1周前
, 18F
06/10 14:57, 18F
推
06/10 14:58,
1周前
, 19F
06/10 14:58, 19F

推
06/10 14:58,
1周前
, 20F
06/10 14:58, 20F
推
06/10 14:59,
1周前
, 21F
06/10 14:59, 21F
→
06/10 14:59,
1周前
, 22F
06/10 14:59, 22F
推
06/10 15:00,
1周前
, 23F
06/10 15:00, 23F
推
06/10 15:00,
1周前
, 24F
06/10 15:00, 24F
推
06/10 15:00,
1周前
, 25F
06/10 15:00, 25F
→
06/10 15:00,
1周前
, 26F
06/10 15:00, 26F
→
06/10 15:01,
1周前
, 27F
06/10 15:01, 27F
→
06/10 15:01,
1周前
, 28F
06/10 15:01, 28F
→
06/10 15:01,
1周前
, 29F
06/10 15:01, 29F
→
06/10 15:01,
1周前
, 30F
06/10 15:01, 30F
→
06/10 15:01,
1周前
, 31F
06/10 15:01, 31F
推
06/10 15:01,
1周前
, 32F
06/10 15:01, 32F
推
06/10 15:01,
1周前
, 33F
06/10 15:01, 33F
→
06/10 15:01,
1周前
, 34F
06/10 15:01, 34F
推
06/10 15:01,
1周前
, 35F
06/10 15:01, 35F
→
06/10 15:02,
1周前
, 36F
06/10 15:02, 36F
推
06/10 15:02,
1周前
, 37F
06/10 15:02, 37F
推
06/10 15:02,
1周前
, 38F
06/10 15:02, 38F
推
06/10 15:02,
1周前
, 39F
06/10 15:02, 39F
還有 346 則推文
還有 5 段內文
推
06/10 19:15,
1周前
, 386F
06/10 19:15, 386F
推
06/10 19:16,
1周前
, 387F
06/10 19:16, 387F
推
06/10 19:17,
1周前
, 388F
06/10 19:17, 388F
推
06/10 19:26,
1周前
, 389F
06/10 19:26, 389F
推
06/10 19:33,
1周前
, 390F
06/10 19:33, 390F
推
06/10 19:36,
1周前
, 391F
06/10 19:36, 391F
推
06/10 19:48,
1周前
, 392F
06/10 19:48, 392F

推
06/10 19:49,
1周前
, 393F
06/10 19:49, 393F
推
06/10 19:51,
1周前
, 394F
06/10 19:51, 394F
推
06/10 19:52,
1周前
, 395F
06/10 19:52, 395F
→
06/10 20:05,
1周前
, 396F
06/10 20:05, 396F
推
06/10 20:10,
1周前
, 397F
06/10 20:10, 397F
推
06/10 20:13,
1周前
, 398F
06/10 20:13, 398F
推
06/10 20:23,
1周前
, 399F
06/10 20:23, 399F
→
06/10 20:54,
1周前
, 400F
06/10 20:54, 400F
推
06/10 20:58,
1周前
, 401F
06/10 20:58, 401F
推
06/10 20:59,
1周前
, 402F
06/10 20:59, 402F
推
06/10 21:05,
1周前
, 403F
06/10 21:05, 403F
推
06/10 21:22,
1周前
, 404F
06/10 21:22, 404F
推
06/10 21:26,
1周前
, 405F
06/10 21:26, 405F
推
06/10 21:36,
1周前
, 406F
06/10 21:36, 406F
→
06/10 21:41,
1周前
, 407F
06/10 21:41, 407F
→
06/10 22:00,
1周前
, 408F
06/10 22:00, 408F
推
06/10 22:00,
1周前
, 409F
06/10 22:00, 409F
推
06/10 22:11,
1周前
, 410F
06/10 22:11, 410F
→
06/10 22:48,
1周前
, 411F
06/10 22:48, 411F
推
06/10 23:32,
1周前
, 412F
06/10 23:32, 412F
→
06/10 23:44,
1周前
, 413F
06/10 23:44, 413F
推
06/10 23:50,
1周前
, 414F
06/10 23:50, 414F
推
06/11 00:37,
1周前
, 415F
06/11 00:37, 415F
→
06/11 00:37,
1周前
, 416F
06/11 00:37, 416F
推
06/11 00:43,
1周前
, 417F
06/11 00:43, 417F
推
06/11 02:08,
1周前
, 418F
06/11 02:08, 418F
→
06/11 08:30,
1周前
, 419F
06/11 08:30, 419F
推
06/11 08:41,
1周前
, 420F
06/11 08:41, 420F
推
06/11 11:12,
1周前
, 421F
06/11 11:12, 421F
推
06/11 14:02,
1周前
, 422F
06/11 14:02, 422F
推
06/11 16:12,
1周前
, 423F
06/11 16:12, 423F
→
06/11 16:12,
1周前
, 424F
06/11 16:12, 424F
推
06/12 07:25,
1周前
, 425F
06/12 07:25, 425F