[問卦] 聽歌是旋律好聽，那RAP歌是好聽在那？消失
像
Kendrick Lamar
Drake
等等的RAP歌
從頭到尾都在唸
然後你還要去找lyric邊看邊聽
但重點是：到底是好聽在那？
像Kendrick Lamar的humble這首歌，不過是一篇文章而已
聽人家唸完一篇文章而已，又沒有好聽的旋律，到底是好聽在哪？
Drake跟KL分別是各兩屆Grammy的最大贏家
所以總覺得這就好像OSCAR有時會有一些冷門電影得大獎，但看完後還是很難懂
這到底是好看在哪？？？？
用一個例子來解釋的更清楚
以KL的這首：
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GF8aaTu2kg0
KL除了RAP外，這首歌本身旋律很好聽，所以我能理解有人喜歡這首歌的理由1
但再以KL的下面這首Humble：
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tvTRZJ-4EyI
你把RAP拿掉後，你會發現HUMBLE這首的旋律就是固定，就是大部份RAP歌
用的「底」，也就是「沒有意義的旋律」。
所以HUMBLE這首歌，就只有RAP，那你根本就只是在聽KL唸經而已....
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 42.72.59.127
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1505163549.A.395.html
※ 編輯: cycutom (42.72.59.127), 09/12/2017 05:00:54
噓
09/12 04:59, , 1F
09/12 04:59, 1F
→
09/12 05:00, , 2F
09/12 05:00, 2F
噓
09/12 05:00, , 3F
09/12 05:00, 3F
噓
09/12 05:00, , 4F
09/12 05:00, 4F
→
09/12 05:00, , 5F
09/12 05:00, 5F
噓
09/12 05:00, , 6F
09/12 05:00, 6F
推
09/12 05:00, , 7F
09/12 05:00, 7F
→
09/12 05:00, , 8F
09/12 05:00, 8F
噓
09/12 05:01, , 9F
09/12 05:01, 9F
推
09/12 05:02, , 10F
09/12 05:02, 10F
我也在想是不是這樣..... = =
※ 編輯: cycutom (42.72.59.127), 09/12/2017 05:02:49
推
09/12 05:02, , 11F
09/12 05:02, 11F
→
09/12 05:02, , 12F
09/12 05:02, 12F
噓
09/12 05:03, , 13F
09/12 05:03, 13F
噓
09/12 05:03, , 14F
09/12 05:03, 14F
→
09/12 05:03, , 15F
09/12 05:03, 15F
→
09/12 05:03, , 16F
09/12 05:03, 16F
→
09/12 05:04, , 17F
09/12 05:04, 17F
推
09/12 05:04, , 18F
09/12 05:04, 18F
※ 編輯: cycutom (42.72.59.127), 09/12/2017 05:07:50
→
09/12 05:05, , 19F
09/12 05:05, 19F
噓
09/12 05:05, , 20F
09/12 05:05, 20F
→
09/12 05:06, , 21F
09/12 05:06, 21F
→
09/12 05:06, , 22F
09/12 05:06, 22F
※ 編輯: cycutom (42.72.59.127), 09/12/2017 05:08:21
噓
09/12 05:08, , 23F
09/12 05:08, 23F
→
09/12 05:10, , 24F
09/12 05:10, 24F
→
09/12 05:19, , 25F
09/12 05:19, 25F
噓
09/12 05:40, , 26F
09/12 05:40, 26F
→
09/12 06:04, , 27F
09/12 06:04, 27F
推
09/12 06:13, , 28F
09/12 06:13, 28F
推
09/12 07:06, , 29F
09/12 07:06, 29F
噓
09/12 08:34, , 30F
09/12 08:34, 30F
推
09/12 08:36, , 31F
09/12 08:36, 31F