[問題]問一題 CR1000的 TEST B 第二題..

看板GMAT作者 (好多東西)時間16年前 (2008/08/26 21:04), 編輯推噓4(4010)
留言14則, 3人參與, 最新討論串1/1
In the years since the city of London imposed strict air-pollution regulations on local industry, the number of bird species seen in and around London has increased dramatically. Similar air-pollution rules should be imposed in other major cities. Each of the following is an assumption made in the argument above EXCEPT: (A) In most major cities, air-pollution problems are caused almost entirely by local industry. (B) Air-pollution regulations on industry have a significant impact on the quality of the air. (C) The air-pollution problems of other major cities are basically similar to those once suffered by London. (D) An increase in the number of bird species in and around a city is desirable. (E) The increased sightings of bird species in and around London reflect an actual increase in the number of species in the area. 我在A跟D之間想了想,最後選 D 我知道 A 不是assumption, 因為London的AP沒提到是誰造成。 想不通的是 D, 我以為這個答案應該是 irrelevant 有人可以麻煩解釋一下 D 嗎? ps.正確答案是A,其他都是假設,A不是 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 118.168.245.146 ※ 編輯: surfingdream 來自: 118.168.245.146 (08/26 21:05)

08/26 21:28, , 1F
你題目是否看錯了 他是問except, A是其中的假設沒錯阿
08/26 21:28, 1F

08/26 21:29, , 2F
題目說 空污的規範是針對倫敦地區的工業 今天這規範要用在其
08/26 21:29, 2F

08/26 21:29, , 3F
他城市的話 空污的起因也應該是那地方的工業才是
08/26 21:29, 3F

08/26 21:40, , 4F
D的意思大概是說 鳥品種的增加對城市而言是件令人期待的事情
08/26 21:40, 4F

08/26 21:41, , 5F
但是題目只把鳥增加視為空氣改善的結果 並未說明當初解決空污
08/26 21:41, 5F

08/26 21:41, , 6F
的用意 所以D作為假設就顯為薄弱了些
08/26 21:41, 6F

08/26 23:08, , 7F
正確答案是A, 所以A不是假設喔!
08/26 23:08, 7F
※ 編輯: surfingdream 來自: 118.168.241.116 (08/26 23:09)

08/26 23:12, , 8F
好吧 換人
08/26 23:12, 8F

08/26 23:37, , 9F
http://ohaha.net/ol5e 這裡有些討論 關鍵出在entirely吧
08/26 23:37, 9F

08/26 23:46, , 10F
呵呵,其實我也有去看,A我想是沒問題
08/26 23:46, 10F

08/26 23:46, , 11F
重點是D為何不是例外,後來我把D加個 "not" desire
08/26 23:46, 11F

08/26 23:48, , 12F
如果不是 desirable 看來就會破壞原本argument
08/26 23:48, 12F

08/26 23:48, , 13F
所以它是 assumption
08/26 23:48, 13F

08/27 01:19, , 14F
Why (E) is an assumption for the question??????
08/27 01:19, 14F
文章代碼(AID): #18i_zCkU (GMAT)