[文法]動詞主被動型態討論

看板Eng-Class作者 (虛無飄渺)時間8年前 (2016/02/11 00:16), 8年前編輯推噓5(5推 0噓 9→)
留言14則, 5人參與, 最新討論串1/1
如題，一個題目，兩個想討論的重點 Q: Returning to my apartment,________. A)my watch was missing. B)I found my watch disappear. C)I found my watch was missing. D)the watch was missed 答案是C，基本上因不符合分詞構句，選項AD不討論 想討論第一點 : watch"不見"應該是被動，C是否可以改成 I found my watch missed(被動句?) 想討論第二點 : 解答寫說B只要改成I found my watch had disappeared就正確 如果根據C的邏輯，為何不是改成I found my watch was disappearing? 歡迎大大賜教討論。 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 58.99.62.52 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1455120969.A.7DB.html ※ 編輯: b9606022 (58.99.62.52), 02/11/2016 00:16:36
→
02/11 00:18, , 1F
Missing (adj.) absent, not found, lost.
02/11 00:18, 1F
推
02/11 01:54, , 2F
disappear是瞬間動詞 沒有進行式
02/11 01:54, 2F
推
02/11 08:36, , 3F
missing是形容詞，I found my watch disappearing還可
02/11 08:36, 3F
推
02/11 11:14, , 4F
二樓，瞬間動詞是沒有完成式。
02/11 11:14, 4F
推
02/11 16:20, , 5F
瞬間動詞可以有完成式，只是不能跟表「持續一段時間」
02/11 16:20, 5F
→
02/11 16:21, , 6F
的時間副詞連用。瞬間動詞也可以有進行式。
02/11 16:21, 6F
→
02/11 22:08, , 7F
大家的看法頗不一的
02/11 22:08, 7F
→
02/11 22:14, , 8F
請問所以disappear是瞬間動詞，必須+had才能表示已經
02/11 22:14, 8F
→
02/11 22:15, , 9F
不見的這個意思嗎? 如果用原形會變成正在不見的意思?
02/11 22:15, 9F
推
02/12 00:00, , 10F
my watch was disappearing.文法沒錯，但語意很怪。但
02/12 00:00, 10F
→
02/12 00:01, , 11F
你說 sunset is disappearing. 還比較合理些
02/12 00:01, 11F
→
02/12 00:02, , 12F
My watch was disappearing等於是說它在你眼前慢慢消失不
02/12 00:02, 12F
→
02/12 00:02, , 13F
折與現實很難符合
02/12 00:02, 13F
→
02/12 00:02, , 14F
這*
02/12 00:02, 14F
‣ 更多 b9606022 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1Mks99VR (Eng-Class)