[發音] which 跟 of which

看板Eng-Class作者 (living for love)時間10年前 (2015/07/02 18:49), 編輯推噓2(2推 0噓 11→)
留言13則, 8人參與, 最新討論串1/1
1. I showed Mary a book, the gift of which my father had given me. 2. I showed Mary a book, the gift which my father had given me. 請問 1 跟 2 有什麼不同啊? 謝謝 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 140.112.121.113 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1435834171.A.81E.html
→
07/03 15:20, , 1F
主詞不同 只有我覺得句子怪怪的嗎
07/03 15:20, 1F
推
07/03 20:20, , 2F
覺得怪是少了個介係詞？
07/03 20:20, 2F
→
07/04 04:52, , 3F
這句子不成立吧？
07/04 04:52, 3F
→
07/04 04:53, , 4F
I showed Mary a book which my father had given me.
07/04 04:53, 4F
→
07/04 07:14, , 5F
大概是1可能有父親還有給其他東西的意思 2就只有一
07/04 07:14, 5F
→
07/04 07:14, , 6F
份禮物
07/04 07:14, 6F
→
07/04 07:16, , 7F
2一定成立
07/04 07:16, 7F
→
07/04 08:47, , 8F
1 > 我給Mary看的那本書不一定是爸爸給我的那本
07/04 08:47, 8F
→
07/04 08:48, , 9F
2 > 同位語，所以是同一本
07/04 08:48, 9F
→
07/04 09:41, , 10F
就像kai大講的 原po可能要查一下of which的用法
07/04 09:41, 10F
→
07/04 23:30, , 11F
原意是要強調這本書就是父親給的那本
07/04 23:30, 11F
→
07/04 23:31, , 12F
其實我是寫2 但外國人幫我改成1 我不解為什麼
07/04 23:31, 12F
推
07/05 08:51, , 13F
２成立
07/05 08:51, 13F
‣ 更多 iplfl 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1LbHSxWU (Eng-Class)