[文法] 過去完成式可用since嗎

看板Eng-Class作者 (Moon)時間13年前 (2012/03/13 10:38), 編輯推噓0(0推 0噓 8→)
留言8則, 5人參與, 最新討論串1/1
今天遇到一個題目 Since they _____ married, they _____ in Taiwan. 答案是 Since they got married, they have lived in Taiwan. 但有另一組答案疑惑了我 Since they got married, they had lived in Taiwan. 請問這句話哪裡錯了? 又該怎麼改才會是正確的呢?! 謝謝! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 163.27.185.81
→
03/13 11:15, , 1F
如果該件事件到現在還是在持續發生的 就用have+pp
03/13 11:15, 1F
→
03/13 14:45, , 2F
had 就錯了
03/13 14:45, 2F
→
03/13 15:38, , 3F
since they got married, they had lived in Taiwan until
03/13 15:38, 3F
→
03/13 15:38, , 4F
last year they went back to America.
03/13 15:38, 4F
→
03/13 16:58, , 5F
不知道為何...我覺得原句怪怪的... Since they got
03/13 16:58, 5F
→
03/13 16:59, , 6F
married, they have been living in Taiwan
03/13 16:59, 6F
→
03/13 16:59, , 7F
我覺得用 have been V-ing比較合乎一般常情的感覺...
03/13 16:59, 7F
→
03/15 21:19, , 8F
Thanks
03/15 21:19, 8F
‣ 更多 shingmoon 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1FNhD3oc (Eng-Class)