[請益] was、has been或had been?

看板Eng-Class作者 (Bristina Aguipears' Luv)時間12年前 (2012/03/07 14:08), 編輯推噓10(10016)
留言26則, 11人參與, 5年前最新討論串1/1
The island of Taiwan, which _____ shaped tens of millions of years ago by continuous tectonic movements, lies in a complex area between two plates and has a unique natural environment. 這是我同學教補習班遇到的一題填空題, 學生的學校老師給的答案是has been, 但時態用的是tens of millions of years ago, 所以has been一定不對呀! 我覺得was和had been好像都可以, 大家覺得呢? -- 【Seizing My Days】 Britney Spears is my virtue, and Christina Aguilera is the demon I cling to. -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 61.219.70.233

03/07 14:29, , 1F
我覺得用過去式就好 用present perfect有點怪
03/07 14:29, 1F

03/07 14:48, , 2F
應該用was had been不行。
03/07 14:48, 2F

03/07 15:45, , 3F
我第一個想到的答案是was,但覺得had been好像也對!XD
03/07 15:45, 3F

03/07 15:50, , 4F
有標出時間的 應該是用過去簡單式 had been記得不行
03/07 15:50, 4F

03/07 16:21, , 6F
past perfect+ago不太ok 可能要+previously或before比較好
03/07 16:21, 6F

03/07 16:31, , 7F
我也覺得was沒問題,但我朋友在臉書上問,結果三種答案
03/07 16:31, 7F

03/07 16:32, , 8F
都有人回!XD不過可以確定的是,我是第一個跟他說was的
03/07 16:32, 8F

03/07 16:32, , 9F
人!哈哈哈哈!
03/07 16:32, 9F

03/07 17:43, , 10F
我去知識+問,有人講解得不錯,大家可以來參考!
03/07 17:43, 10F

03/07 17:43, , 11F

03/07 21:08, , 12F
後面有接 continuous 表目前為止不斷的所以用 has
03/07 21:08, 12F

03/07 21:09, , 13F
been
03/07 21:09, 13F

03/07 22:32, , 14F
樓上搞錯囉,沒有目前為止不斷,答案是was
03/07 22:32, 14F

03/07 23:15, , 15F
03/07 23:15, 15F

03/08 03:45, , 16F
因為ago,很明顯地應該用簡單過去式was。出題者也許其實
03/08 03:45, 16F

03/08 03:46, , 17F
想寫has been shaped for tens of millions of years而筆誤
03/08 03:46, 17F

03/08 03:47, , 18F
當然兩者意思完全不同。
03/08 03:47, 18F

03/08 08:00, , 19F
這題目不合邏輯吧 造地運動又不會停止
03/08 08:00, 19F

03/08 10:52, , 20F
我也覺得缺少 for
03/08 10:52, 20F

03/09 15:56, , 21F
答案是was
03/09 15:56, 21F

08/06 07:15, , 22F
後面有接 contin https://muxiv.com
08/06 07:15, 22F

09/06 23:45, , 23F
應該用was had https://daxiv.com
09/06 23:45, 23F

12/02 18:09, , 24F
//muxiv.com
12/02 18:09, 24F

12/02 18:09, , 25F
12/02 18:09, 25F

04/13 22:24, 5年前 , 26F
我也覺得was沒問題, https://moxox.com
04/13 22:24, 26F
文章代碼(AID): #1FLljk5P (Eng-Class)