[請益] 一題文法

看板Eng-Class作者 (新的開始)時間14年前 (2012/02/21 00:42), 編輯推噓0(0推 0噓 17→)
留言17則, 4人參與, 最新討論串3/5 (看更多)
He claimed he had been abducted by aliens and he was given exams after taken aboard their spaceships. 這句哪裡文法有誤? (A) had been abducted (B) and he was (C) given exams (D) after taken (E) aboard 答案是(B) 請教為什麼呢? 萬分感謝! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 112.104.15.166
→
02/21 00:50, , 1F
and he was --> and that he was
02/21 00:50, 1F
→
02/21 00:53, , 2F
thank you so much:)
02/21 00:53, 2F
→
02/21 01:36, , 3F
這題目出得不甚好。(D)是明顯的文法錯誤: after(介)+名詞(
02/21 01:36, 3F
→
02/21 01:36, , 4F
片語)，所以之後要用gerund phrase(功能上是名詞) ->
02/21 01:36, 4F
→
02/21 01:36, , 5F
being taken aboard ... 那個"being"不能省
02/21 01:36, 5F
→
02/21 01:36, , 6F
(B)的話直接拿掉 he 即可。加上 that 反而比拿掉 he 更糟
02/21 01:36, 6F
→
02/21 01:37, , 7F
糕。參考:
02/21 01:37, 7F
→
02/21 01:37, , 9F
找: 以下的例子都是用同一句，然後比較有無that的差別
02/21 01:37, 9F
→
02/21 01:37, , 10F
我會說這題出得不甚好是因為and之後重複出現的 he 的取捨
02/21 01:37, 10F
→
02/21 01:37, , 11F
很多時候是基於"style"考量，倒不一定是文法對錯。總之若(
02/21 01:37, 11F
→
02/21 01:38, , 12F
B)是答案，那麼(D)肯定也是答案 (B/D長得很像，我猜是答案
02/21 01:38, 12F
→
02/21 01:38, , 13F
字母打錯了)
02/21 01:38, 13F
→
02/21 23:49, , 14F
D大 謝謝，想請教D如果對的話是否可解釋為分詞構句
02/21 23:49, 14F
→
08/06 07:13, , 15F
D大 謝謝，想請教D https://noxiv.com
08/06 07:13, 15F
→
09/06 23:43, , 16F
after(介)+名詞 https://daxiv.com
09/06 23:43, 16F
→
12/02 18:08, , 17F
after(介)+名詞 https://noxiv.com
12/02 18:08, 17F
‣ 更多 aphroditeyeh 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1FGdVVaS (Eng-Class)
‣ 更多 aphroditeyeh 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1FGdVVaS (Eng-Class)