[文法] 有關係代名詞的兩個句子

看板Eng-Class作者時間14年前 (2011/04/11 01:29), 編輯推噓3(305)
留言8則, 5人參與, 最新討論串1/1
想請問含有關係代名詞的兩個句子。 原來的句子是 You mentioned the man. 你提到這個人。 The man happens to be my uncle. 這個人碰巧是我叔叔。 用關係代名詞(whom)連接兩句,變成 The man whom you mentioned happens to be my uncle. 你提到的那個人碰巧是我叔叔 。 但是,用who似乎也行,變成是 You mentioned the man who happens to be my uncle. 文法看來沒有錯,可是意思有跟上句(whom)一樣嗎? 用who連接兩句也可以嗎? -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 218.167.2.146

04/11 07:09, , 1F
你的句子有誤
04/11 07:09, 1F

04/11 10:11, , 2F
第2句 ,who happens
04/11 10:11, 2F

04/11 12:16, , 3F
You mentioned the man. (句子怪怪的)
04/11 12:16, 3F

04/11 12:17, , 4F
個人意見啦
04/11 12:17, 4F

04/11 12:53, , 5F
You mentioned the man. 個人看不出哪裡怪
04/11 12:53, 5F

04/11 14:45, , 6F
You mentioned a man或You mentioned that man吧
04/11 14:45, 6F

04/11 22:47, , 7F
可是原句是You mentioned the man
04/11 22:47, 7F

04/12 06:47, , 8F
The man whom/who/that/省略 you mentioned... 4種說法皆可
04/12 06:47, 8F
文章代碼(AID): #1DeUZrq3 (Eng-Class)