[文法] By the time

看板Eng-Class作者 (= =)時間15年前 (2011/03/24 15:26), 編輯推噓4(4推 0噓 10→)
留言14則, 4人參與, 最新討論串1/1
想請問各位一句文法 By the time _____________, Norman Rockwell had decided that he wanted to bean artist (A). in his early teens (B). he was in his early teens 答案是什麼? 直覺感覺應該是a 不過請問各位有人知道為什麼b是錯的嗎? -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 114.32.9.209
→
03/24 15:36, , 1F
因為代名詞出現在替代的名詞之前?
03/24 15:36, 1F
→
03/24 15:39, , 2F
個人覺得答案應該是B，「by the time (that) + 完整子句」
03/24 15:39, 2F
→
03/24 15:39, , 3F
似乎是比較常見的慣用法...
03/24 15:39, 3F
→
03/24 15:42, , 4F
不過我始終覺得這個句子用by the time有種說不出的違和感
03/24 15:42, 4F
→
03/24 15:55, , 5F
請native speaker說說吧，因為感覺這邊by the time用得很怪
03/24 15:55, 5F
→
03/24 15:56, , 6F
這邊應該是用when比較正確
03/24 15:56, 6F
推
03/24 16:08, , 7F
B +1 ， by the time+副詞子句
03/24 16:08, 7F
→
03/24 16:26, , 8F
不過說真的直覺怎麼會是a呢...有沒有標準答案?
03/24 16:26, 8F
推
03/24 16:30, , 9F
ok，違和感來自於我之前句子看太少，因為比較少看到by the
03/24 16:30, 9F
→
03/24 16:30, , 10F
time+ 狀態(尤其是年紀)的句子，看比較多的是+動作，但剛
03/24 16:30, 10F
→
03/24 16:31, , 11F
剛以「書籍」為範圍搜尋google，看到滿多例子的，所以應該
03/24 16:31, 11F
→
03/24 16:31, , 12F
是沒問題的~
03/24 16:31, 12F
推
03/24 21:17, , 13F
直覺是b) by the time (when) he is in his ...
03/24 21:17, 13F
推
03/24 21:19, , 14F
真的要像a) 用名詞的話 Before teenage 就好了，何必費事
03/24 21:19, 14F
‣ 更多 tang29 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1DYl8OSz (Eng-Class)