[文法] but什麼時候該加逗點?

看板Eng-Class作者 (阿郁)時間15年前 (2011/01/26 22:03), 編輯推噓2(206)
留言8則, 3人參與, 最新討論串1/1
請問使用but甚麼時候該加逗點呢? 為什麼有時候要加,有時又不用加呢? 例子1:不加, When Mr Ben Ali, newly installed as interior minister, ousted the ageing but respected president in a palace coup in 1987, he was greeted as a needed breath of fresh air. 例子2:加, Some units did enter the capital, but refused to use force against protesters, who greeted them with cheers. 感恩解惑~~~ -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 118.169.174.240 ※ 編輯: MEGAR127 來自: 118.169.174.240 (01/26 22:03) ※ 編輯: MEGAR127 來自: 118.169.174.240 (01/26 22:04)

01/26 23:52, , 1F
老師有說過加逗點是避免句子太長,中間略停,其可加或可不加
01/26 23:52, 1F

01/27 00:05, , 2F
跟but所帶入的意義有關。例一 but respected
01/27 00:05, 2F

01/27 00:07, , 3F
可看為 the aging/respected president,but帶入的東
01/27 00:07, 3F

01/27 00:08, , 4F
西很短,並且aging部分不會有逗號,所以but也沒有
01/27 00:08, 4F

01/27 00:09, , 5F
例二but帶入一整句,如果沒逗號會難看懂
01/27 00:09, 5F

01/27 11:17, , 6F
例1本來有兩個逗號 ousted the ageing, but respected,
01/27 11:17, 6F

01/27 11:19, , 7F
president 但在這句子裡不應該用這麼多逗號 不然好像一直
01/27 11:19, 7F

01/27 11:19, , 8F
被打斷的感覺
01/27 11:19, 8F
文章代碼(AID): #1DG2cpIk (Eng-Class)