八年條款卡關 台大教學績優老師不被續聘
2015-09-23 08:02:48 聯合報 記者洪欣慈/台北報導
教師節前夕,各大學紛紛遴選傑出教師表揚,台大園藝及景觀系助理教授李國譚連續六年
獲教學傑出獎,卻因研究未達標準、不符合台大須於八年內升等「八年條款」無法續聘,
原已規畫開設的課程也被暫停,不僅學生權益受影響,也凸顯現有升等機制不利教學型教
師的問題。
台大主秘林達德指出,李曾提出升等申訴,但未通過,今年經三級教評會決議不續聘,並
依校方規定先取消開設的所有課程,但因李目前仍在進行不續聘申訴,仍暫保留教師資格。
林達德坦言,李不續聘「是制度問題」,李在教學上相當受肯定,但依學校升等條件,須
同時具備教學、研究及服務三部分,李在研究面向「差一點點」,在制度下只能依規定解
聘,台大也感到相當遺憾。
教學型教師難升等已非首例,過去政大也曾發生獲特優教師的政治系副教授郭立民,因八
年未申請評量、未通過教師基本績效評量,遭校方決議不續聘;當時他便曾公開於政大社
科院表揚優良教師典禮上表達對學界「重研究、輕教學」、限期升等生態的不滿,類似的
問題仍舊存在於校園內。
李國譚說,他到台大今年第九年,去年八月提出升等,教學、服務及研究三塊其實都有達
標,但因研究成果不符學院規定而未通過,不續聘案目前還在教育部審查中,學校就先行
停掉他的課,不只影響他個人,更讓學生權益受損。
他指出,「八年條款」是惡法,過去高等法院曾有多次判例,認為學校不得僅以期限內未
升等不續聘,且每個老師專精領域不同。他著重教學,但也沒有完全荒廢研究,無奈制度
扭曲、偏重研究,無法獲續聘,也讓已選課的學生受到影響。
林達德表示,八年升等條款是淘汰、避免怠惰學者變「萬年教師」的重要考核機制,不太
可能廢除,國外也都有類似做法,但台大已正在研議升等分軌,開闢升等不受研究影響的
教學專任教師管道,避免類似遺憾再度發生。
--
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 114.26.163.147
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/AfterPhD/M.1443010792.A.7D3.html
推
09/23 20:23, , 1F
09/23 20:23, 1F
→
09/23 20:23, , 2F
09/23 20:23, 2F
推
09/23 20:24, , 3F
09/23 20:24, 3F
→
09/23 20:25, , 4F
09/23 20:25, 4F
→
09/23 20:25, , 5F
09/23 20:25, 5F
→
09/23 20:25, , 6F
09/23 20:25, 6F
→
09/23 20:26, , 7F
09/23 20:26, 7F
→
09/23 20:26, , 8F
09/23 20:26, 8F
推
09/23 20:34, , 9F
09/23 20:34, 9F
→
09/23 20:34, , 10F
09/23 20:34, 10F
→
09/23 20:35, , 11F
09/23 20:35, 11F
→
09/23 20:36, , 12F
09/23 20:36, 12F
→
09/23 20:37, , 13F
09/23 20:37, 13F
→
09/23 20:39, , 14F
09/23 20:39, 14F
→
09/23 20:40, , 15F
09/23 20:40, 15F
推
09/23 20:40, , 16F
09/23 20:40, 16F
→
09/23 20:41, , 17F
09/23 20:41, 17F
推
09/23 20:42, , 18F
09/23 20:42, 18F
→
09/23 20:43, , 19F
09/23 20:43, 19F
→
09/23 20:43, , 20F
09/23 20:43, 20F
→
09/23 20:43, , 21F
09/23 20:43, 21F
→
09/23 20:43, , 22F
09/23 20:43, 22F
→
09/23 20:44, , 23F
09/23 20:44, 23F
→
09/23 20:46, , 24F
09/23 20:46, 24F
→
09/23 20:46, , 25F
09/23 20:46, 25F
→
09/23 20:47, , 26F
09/23 20:47, 26F
→
09/23 20:48, , 27F
09/23 20:48, 27F
→
09/23 20:52, , 28F
09/23 20:52, 28F
→
09/23 20:55, , 29F
09/23 20:55, 29F
推
09/23 21:51, , 30F
09/23 21:51, 30F
→
09/23 22:05, , 31F
09/23 22:05, 31F
→
09/23 22:05, , 32F
09/23 22:05, 32F
→
09/23 22:06, , 33F
09/23 22:06, 33F
→
09/23 22:06, , 34F
09/23 22:06, 34F
推
09/23 22:07, , 35F
09/23 22:07, 35F
→
09/23 22:08, , 36F
09/23 22:08, 36F
→
09/23 22:09, , 37F
09/23 22:09, 37F
→
09/23 22:24, , 38F
09/23 22:24, 38F
→
09/23 22:47, , 39F
09/23 22:47, 39F
→
09/23 22:47, , 40F
09/23 22:47, 40F
→
09/23 22:48, , 41F
09/23 22:48, 41F
→
09/23 22:48, , 42F
09/23 22:48, 42F
→
09/23 22:48, , 43F
09/23 22:48, 43F
推
09/23 23:11, , 44F
09/23 23:11, 44F
→
09/23 23:12, , 45F
09/23 23:12, 45F
→
09/23 23:23, , 46F
09/23 23:23, 46F
→
09/23 23:24, , 47F
09/23 23:24, 47F
→
09/23 23:26, , 48F
09/23 23:26, 48F
→
09/23 23:27, , 49F
09/23 23:27, 49F
推
09/23 23:46, , 50F
09/23 23:46, 50F
推
09/23 23:46, , 51F
09/23 23:46, 51F
→
09/24 00:50, , 52F
09/24 00:50, 52F
→
09/24 00:52, , 53F
09/24 00:52, 53F
→
09/24 00:53, , 54F
09/24 00:53, 54F
→
09/24 00:54, , 55F
09/24 00:54, 55F
推
09/24 09:52, , 56F
09/24 09:52, 56F
→
09/24 09:53, , 57F
09/24 09:53, 57F
推
09/24 09:56, , 58F
09/24 09:56, 58F
→
09/24 09:58, , 59F
09/24 09:58, 59F
推
09/24 20:26, , 60F
09/24 20:26, 60F
→
09/24 20:26, , 61F
09/24 20:26, 61F
→
09/24 20:27, , 62F
09/24 20:27, 62F
→
09/24 20:30, , 63F
09/24 20:30, 63F
→
09/24 20:31, , 64F
09/24 20:31, 64F
→
09/24 20:31, , 65F
09/24 20:31, 65F
→
09/24 20:32, , 66F
09/24 20:32, 66F
→
09/24 20:33, , 67F
09/24 20:33, 67F
推
09/24 21:13, , 68F
09/24 21:13, 68F
推
09/24 23:32, , 69F
09/24 23:32, 69F
→
09/24 23:33, , 70F
09/24 23:33, 70F
推
09/24 23:50, , 71F
09/24 23:50, 71F
→
09/24 23:51, , 72F
09/24 23:51, 72F
→
09/25 01:58, , 73F
09/25 01:58, 73F